Climber Fall on "Lurking Fear"

October 08, 2015 Posted by: Yosemite Search and Rescue

Helicopter lands in a meadow as people look on

On Monday, September 19, 2015, at approximately 5:30 pm, Yosemite Search and Rescue (YOSAR) received a report that a climber had taken a 50-foot fall. The climber was on a climbing route called Lurking Fear, which is located on the western edge of El Capitan, and was reportedly was suffering serious injuries, including possible head trauma and a broken clavicle.

The reporting party was another climbing team on Lurking Fear. While cell service was poor, YOSAR was able to determine approximately where the climber was and vaguely what had happened. YOSAR used a spotting scope to locate the injured party approximately three quarters of the way up the route. Using a megaphone and hand signals, YOSAR was eventually able to make contact with the partner of the injured climber. From this initial size-up, the partner indicated that the injured climber had a possibly broken clavicle and had not lost consciousness. Given the late hour and the perception that the injured climber had not lost consciousness, YOSAR postponed rescue operations until the following morning.

Helicopter performing a short haulOn Sunday, at 7 am, YOSAR began rescue operations out of El Capitan Meadow. Park Helicopter 551 performed a reconnaissance flight, which helped rescuers determine that lowering rescuers from the top of El Capitan would be incredibly difficult and potentially more hazardous than a short-haul mission using Helicopter 551. Short-haul missions involve suspending a rescuer 150-250 feet below the helicopter, flying them to the scene of the accident, and placing them directly onto the side of the cliff.

Helicopter 551 inserted two rescuers at the injured climber and the rescuers packaged the patient for extraction. Helicopter 551 then retrieved the injured climber, the two rescuers, and a substantial amount of the climber’s gear. The injured climber was then transferred to an ambulance. The partner of the injured climber was absorbed by another climbing team and continued to the top.

After speaking with the injured climber, rangers determined that the climber was using direct aid climbing (the climber was using specialized gear to make progress up the route). The last thing the injured climber remembered was placing a red micro cam and stepping into the ladder to weigh it. Speaking with other climbers on scene, it appears that the top piece of gear failed and proceeded to pull at least two more pieces before being caught by a number four cam. The uninjured partner was able to lower the climber to a ledge and then descend down to assist him. Whereas megaphone communications had led YOSAR to believe the climber had not lost consciousness, follow up interviews with adjacent climbing groups revealed that they had believed the injured climber had a severely deformed helmet and had been going in and out of consciousness, and that the climber had what appeared to be a broken clavicle.

The injured climber and his partner were joined by two additional teams of climbers. The fellow climbers reportedly monitored the injured climber through the night and stayed on scene until the completion of the short-haul mission the next day.

Lessons Learned

The placement of multiple questionable pieces of gear (which were used to provide protection in case of a fall) in a row was perhaps the main contributing factor to this accident. Perhaps most importantly, this is a reminder of how helpful helmets can be in preventing serious head trauma. According to medical personnel on scene, it is very likely that the climber’s head injuries would have been much more substantial had the climber not been wearing a helmet.

It is important to remember that climbing above ledges increases the likelihood of a lead climber fall causing significant injuries. In this accident, the lead climber was starting off a large and tiered ledge system that the climber may have struck during the fall. Climbers, especially at the end of the day when they are tired and mentally exhausted, are more prone to making mistakes and overlooking safety details. Being cognizant of your own fatigue— as well as your partner’s—is an important part of staying safe on the wall.


12 Comments Comments icon

  1. October 18, 2015 at 06:57
     

    Who pays for search and rescue? A search and rescue exercise is not required by the average person, who does not need it. Every search and rescue is an extraordinary event that costs thousands, maybe tens of thousands of dollars. Taxpayers should not have to pay for search and rescue, and neither should park visitors pay with park fees. If a person is in a car accident, they are charged, personally or through their insurance, to pay the expense for damages to themselves and others, and to pay for damages to property, and hospitalization, emergency services, and to pay for ambulance rides, et cetera. So it should be for these stupid accidents in Yosemite. All climbers, hikers, visitors, whomever should be required to carry insurance, and/or pay the expense of any and all search and rescue. Sure, search and rescue those incurring these preventable events, but pay for rescue themselves. Otherwise, stay off the rocks!

     
  2. October 18, 2015 at 06:57
     

    Who pays for search and rescue? A search and rescue exercise is not required by the average person, who does not need it. Every search and rescue is an extraordinary event that costs thousands, maybe tens of thousands of dollars. Taxpayers should not have to pay for search and rescue, and neither should park visitors pay with park fees. If a person is in a car accident, they are charged, personally or through their insurance, to pay the expense for damages to themselves and others, and to pay for damages to property, and hospitalization, emergency services, and to pay for ambulance rides, et cetera. So it should be for these stupid accidents in Yosemite. All climbers, hikers, visitors, whomever should be required to carry insurance, and/or pay the expense of any and all search and rescue. Sure, search and rescue those incurring these preventable events, but pay for rescue themselves. Otherwise, stay off the rocks!

     
  3. October 18, 2015 at 06:57
     

    Who pays for search and rescue? A search and rescue exercise is not required by the average person, who does not need it. Every search and rescue is an extraordinary event that costs thousands, maybe tens of thousands of dollars. Taxpayers should not have to pay for search and rescue, and neither should park visitors pay with park fees. If a person is in a car accident, they are charged, personally or through their insurance, to pay the expense for damages to themselves and others, and to pay for damages to property, and hospitalization, emergency services, and to pay for ambulance rides, et cetera. So it should be for these stupid accidents in Yosemite. All climbers, hikers, visitors, whomever should be required to carry insurance, and/or pay the expense of any and all search and rescue. Sure, search and rescue those incurring these preventable events, but pay for rescue themselves. Otherwise, stay off the rocks!

     
  4. October 14, 2015 at 11:56
     

    Thanks Yosar for resueing our friend!

     
  5. October 14, 2015 at 11:56
     

    Thanks Yosar for resueing our friend!

     
  6. October 14, 2015 at 11:56
     

    Thanks Yosar for resueing our friend!

     
  7. October 14, 2015 at 11:56
     

    Thanks Yosar for resueing our friend!

     
  8. October 12, 2015 at 05:22
     

    This makes me think about the very real rockfall hazard in Yosemite. (Head strikes rock or rock strikes head - either way, the injury can be fatal.) I would love to see the park promoting the wearing even of bike helmets by hikers. (It's hard for parents to get their kids to wear helmets while hiking, unless it is something that is common.)

     
  9. Dan
    October 12, 2015 at 04:58
     

    One of my dumbest bike accidents.....no make that all three of my bike accidents were at the end of the day when I was super tired.

     
  10. Tim
    October 12, 2015 at 02:13
     

    Amazing rescue, another top job from YOSAR. And awesome to hear another group took the partner of the injured climber into their climbing team and continued to the top.

     
  11. October 12, 2015 at 01:06
     

    I am shocked that climbers are not required to carry some form of communication gear. Im a Ham Radio Operator, there is a repeater in the Valley. FRS radios do not require the license I have but they work well. In my opinion, this should be REQUIRED by the Park Service.

     
  12. October 12, 2015 at 11:54
     

    I am very glad the climber made it out of there alive and that others took care of him throughout the night. I really appreciate the in-depth article so the public can have more of an understanding that while climbing is always risky, it is always the climber's responsibility to have the right gear and safety equipment. Making sound decisions is always key. Thank you for saving him and providing such good information.

     
 
Leave this field empty
Required information

Post A Comment

Last updated: October 8, 2015

Contact the Park

Mailing Address:

PO Box 577
Yosemite National Park, CA 95389

Phone:

(209) 372-0200

Contact Us