As their traditional lifestyle became more difficult to follow, some Kaibab Paiute moved closer to Mormon settlements, such as Kanab. In 1879 the Church gave the Kaibab one-third of the water rights to Moccasin Spring, in part to draw them away from Kanab. They also set up an Indian mission beside Moccasin where the Paiutes were invited to live and learn the ways of agriculture. In the words of an early Mormon resident, it was an attempt "to get them to settle down at Moccasin and live like white people, farming and cattle raising, instead of roaming over the country in search of a living."
In 1873, government explorer and administrator John Wesley Powell recommended that the Kaibab Paiutes be placed under Federal jurisdiction, in order to provide them with food and land for farming. However, no Federal action was taken. Powell then recommended that they move to the Ute or Moapa Paiute reservation. The Utes were their traditional enemies and the Moapa area was too far from their homeland. The Kaibab remained.
The Kanab or Kaibab Indians are in very destitute circumstances; fertile places are now being occupied by the white population, thus cutting off all their means of subsistence except game....The foot hills that yielded hundreds of acres of sunflowers...the grass that grew so luxuriantly when you were here...and many other plants that produced food for the natives is all eat out by stock....I should esteem it a great favor if you could secure some surplus merchandise for the immediate relief of their utter destitution.
Jacob Hamblin to John Wesley Powell, 1880