|
Visit our keyboard shortcuts docs for details
The National Park Service discovered and excavated a Civil War surgeon’s burial pit at Manassas National Battlefield Park. In March 2024, nearly ten years after the first excavation, a National Park Service team returned to the archeological dig site to finish the work.
Smithsonian Institution / Kate D. Sherwood In August 1862, three Union soldiers were among the many wounded at the Battle of Second Manassas. They were brought to a field hospital, but none survived their injuries. Their bodies were laid to rest in a shallow burial pit, placed among amputated limbs from other soldiers injured in the battle. Then they were lost to history. The National Park Service first encountered the pit in 2014, while fulfilling its obligations under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act during a utility project. Over the next decade, two excavations would reveal something extraordinary: the first battlefield surgeon’s burial pit ever excavated and studied at a Civil War battlefield and the remains of three Union soldiers. An Unexpected DiscoveryIn 2014, Manassas National Battlefield Park was carrying out a utility project. Earlier archeological testing had identified nothing significant, but during installation, archeological monitoring unearthed several small fragments of bone. The NPS does not attempt to find human remains, but when they are discovered, the agency is prepared to respond thoughtfully. The National Historic Preservation Act and related laws guide that response, which differs depending on whether the remains are recent, historic, or those of Native Americans. At first, no one knew what the fragments were or how old they were. The NPS sent them to the forensic anthropology lab at the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of Natural History, where researchers determined they were human and dated to the Civil War. A femur, recovered during monitoring, had been sawed off, consistent with an amputation. Because these remains lay close to the surface and were subject to erosion and other processes that may threaten their integrity, the NPS determined that further excavation was needed to study and preserve this rare find.
NPS / Karen Orrence The ExcavationIn 2015, archeologists from the NPS and the Smithsonian removed the earth in a grid pattern, inch by inch, layer by layer, carefully recording every finding and its precise position. Knowing exactly where a bone lay helps scientists understand how the remains were placed and whether damage occurred before or after death. Beneath the surface lay two nearly complete human skeletons and an assemblage of 11 amputated arms and legs, along with artifacts including buttons from a Union sack coat, a .577-caliber Enfield bullet, and three pieces of .31-caliber lead buckshot. Typically, these pits held only amputated limbs, so the discovery of two whole interments was unexpected. To learn more about who these bones belonged to, the NPS collaborated with the Smithsonian’s Physical Anthropology team.
NPS / Nathan King Identifying the SoldiersOnce the remains were moved to the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History, physical anthropologists began detailed analysis and historical research. They analyzed the soldiers’ bone chemistry in an attempt to determine their identities. Carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen isotopes showed that both men had consumed food and water from northern latitudes. Together with the sack coat buttons, this evidence helped identify the remains as those of Union soldiers. Their teeth, joints, and bone structure revealed their ages and likely causes of death.
NPS / Bryan Gorsira A Place of HonorAfter the men were identified as Union soldiers, the Army offered them a permanent resting place at Arlington National Cemetery. On June 19, 2018, the NPS transferred the remains. The 3rd U.S. Infantry Regiment, “The Old Guard,” moved the soldiers to Arlington to await interment. Ahead of the interment ceremony, an NPS historic preservationist and two volunteers built coffins using wood from a wind-felled oak that had grown on the Manassas battlefield. The coffins followed an old-fashioned “toe-pincher” design, wider at the shoulders and narrowing toward the head and feet, and the remains were wrapped in reproduction Civil War blankets. On August 18, 2018, they were finally laid to rest at Arlington, honoring their memory and the sacrifice of so many service members throughout our nation’s history. NPS / Nathan King Returning to the PitWhen the 2015 excavation ended, archeologists already knew that additional amputated bones were still in the ground. They paused to make a plan and coordinate with stakeholders under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. In March 2024, nearly ten years later, an NPS team returned to finish the work. Ground-penetrating radar surveys conducted in 2016 had suggested more limbs were present, and the team worked through the soil with the same meticulous care as before, recording the depth and position of every find on field forms and screening the dirt so nothing was lost. They soon realized they had uncovered not only several limbs, but another complete human skeleton. The team ultimately recovered several amputated limbs, the third soldier’s remains, and artifacts including a number of Union coat buttons and a rubber pocket comb.
NPS / Kelsey Graczyk The Third SoldierOnce the excavation was complete, physical anthropologists cleaned, cataloged, and organized the finds and applied the same analysis used before: bone growth patterns, dental evidence, signs of wartime trauma, and chemical testing. About 164 years later, that analysis allows the NPS to tell this soldier’s story. He was a young man, roughly 15 to 19 years old and slight in stature, between 5 feet 1 inch and 5 feet 3 inches tall. New York Excelsior jacket buttons, identifiable by their shield and eagle design, confirmed he was a Union soldier. In time, isotopic analysis may provide clues about where he grew up. A piece of case shot lodged in his upper chest points to his cause of death: long-range Confederate artillery during the Battle of Second Manassas. Case shot was designed to explode above enemy troops. He may have been struck on the field and died on the way to the hospital, or shortly after reaching it. Like the other two soldiers, his interment in the surgeon’s limb pit was unusual. Matching service and surgeon’s records, which often noted a soldier’s name, regiment, and injury, to all these identifying characteristics may one day reveal exactly who he was.
NPS / Kelsey Graczyk Why No DNA TestingThe primary focus for the unknown soldier was to ensure a proper and respectful burial. There are ethical issues with conducting DNA testing on remains without the consent of descendants. Unlike modern clinical research, where participants provide informed consent, historic and ancient individuals cannot give permission for their bodies and genomes to be studied. Since we don’t know exactly who these individuals are, we also cannot seek permission or support from descendants, who may or may not want DNA testing done. Finally, storing genetic information in semipublic or commercial databases can raise privacy and data security concerns. The NPS will conduct stable isotope analysis and historical research on the third soldier’s remains and the amputated limbs (as it did for the 2015 finds) that, we hope, will help us formally identify these individuals.
NPS / Kelsey Graczyk A Dignified BurialThe National Park Service was once again honored to work with the Office of Army Cemeteries to give this young soldier a dignified burial. On Aug. 13, 2026, the NPS announced its plan to transfer his remains to the Army, and this young man was laid to rest at Arlington National Cemetery on Nov. 4, 2026. He is buried in the same section as the two previously interred Union soldiers. The amputated limbs have not been interred at Arlington; they remain with the NPS for continued osteological analysis. By examining the cuts, researchers can gauge a surgeon’s skill and even his physical position relative to the patient. The surgeon’s records may help identify whose limbs they were. The limbs will continue to be handled with respect and dignity, guided by Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. Discovering these remains has led to valuable research that deepens our understanding of the Second Battle of Manassas and of Civil War medicine. The site is now fully excavated and field work is complete, but the NPS remains committed to preserving America’s battlefield history, advancing archeological research, and honoring those who served. At the battlefield, whether you are walking your dog, taking an interpretive tour, or just admiring the bucolic landscape, you are on hallowed ground. Approximately 164 years ago, on the battlefield’s ridges and hills, soldiers fought and bled to fulfill the promise of a more perfect union. On Aug. 30, 1862, the day all three men were likely wounded, Union troops were ordered across an open field into crushing artillery and withering infantry fire from an elevated, entrenched Confederate position. Like so many others that day, they gave the last full measure doing their duty. The National Park Service, in partnership with the Office of Army Cemeteries, has the honor and privilege of sharing their story. |
Last updated: November 9, 2026