This is an image of historic buildings on East 68th Street in the Upper East Side Historic District. Photo: Courtesy, FRIENDS of the Upper East Side Historic District.
Creating and Using Design Guidelines
Section 'a' content Section 'b' content Section 'c' content Section 'd' content Section 'e' content
National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior with link to ParkNet National Park Service arrowhead with a link to ParkNet

Working on the Past in Local Historic Districts

Design guidelines provide
A basis for making fair decisions
Consistency in design review
Incentives for investment
Property value enhancement
A tool for education

<--Excerpt from the "Benefits of Design Review" by Nore Winter from the Alliance Review, July/August 2001.

Local review of work proposals.
In the design review process, owners of locally designated landmarks and districts must get approval from a locally appointed historic preservation commission or architectural review board for major exterior alterations, additions, and new construction. Commission approval is in the form of a "certificate of appropriateness." To be approved, an application for must meet the design review criteria within the preservation ordinance that a community has adopted. Both the terminology and process may vary somewhat, depending upon the ordinance.

  Example of a local preservation ordinance
  Fairfax County, Virginia
>> FAIRFAX COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE [PDF*], 7-204, Administration of Historic Overlay District Regulations, pp. 7-10 to 7-16.
  Example of an illustrated local design guideline
  Raleigh, North Carolina
>> RALEIGH HISTORIC DISTRICTS COMMISSION [PDF*], Section 4, Additions and New Construction, pp. 51-58.
  *Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader

Clarifying the role of the guidelines.
The topic of local design guidelines always needs to be understood within its relationship to the local preservation ordinance. The ordinance is a law and the design review criteria are part of the law. Design guidelines are not, in and of themselves, mandatory like the ordinance and should not be confused with the ordinance. In most cases, guidelines are just that—helpful, interpretive, explanatory recommendations. Consisting of written and graphic information in a printed, book format, they are key support materials for administering design review and may be used to advantage by commissions, boards, and applicants alike in the review process.

How districts variously use the Secretary's Standards.
The philosophical principles in The Secretary of Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties have been proven to be important in the successful administration of historic districts. Sometimes they are cited within a preservation ordinance as part of the design review criteria. Sometimes they are referenced in the ordinance as the required basis for development of a local design guideline. While some preservation ordinances state that design guidelines "shall be adopted," others state that design guidelines "may be adopted." A few districts may use the Standards for Rehabilitation by themselves—as a general guideline—without creating a specific local design guideline. It can be confusing. The ordinance can remove confusion by specifying which categories of information must be used (e.g., review criteria) and which are only advisory (e.g., guidelines).

Please note if you plan to apply for Federal income tax incentives for historic preservation: Following a local ordinance and local design guidelines--especially if the goal in your historic district is to "restore" historic buildings to an earlier appearance--may be in conflict with the federal "Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation" (36 CFR 67) used to review federal tax credit applications. The expressed goal of rehabilitation is to update historic buildings for continuing and new uses while preserving character-defining features. Be sure to ask your State Historic Preservation Office for guidance early in the planning stages of any Federal income tax incentives project.

NOTE: Print all of Section 'c' in PDF format.