This short video shows how removing non-native trout from selected high-mountain lakes at Sequoia & Kings Canyon National Parks gives native frogs a chance to survive.
6 minutes, 42 seconds
"Plop…plop…splash!" Have you ever heard this sound--a frog hopping in or out of water--or seen a frog or tadpole? Imagine not hearing this sound...wouldn't that be strange?
Animals need a "helping hand" once-in-a-while for survival. For example, mountain yellow-legged frogs (Rana muscosa and Rana sierrae) are amphibians that inhabit naturally fishless lakes, ponds, and streams in the high country of the Sierra Nevada mountains. Once the most numerous amphibians in the Sierra Nevada, today mountain yellow-legged frogs have disappeared from 92% of their historic range. View map of former fishless areas in Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks. As a result, in 2012 Rana muscosa was listed as endangered and Rana sierrae was listed as threatened under the California Endangered Species Act; and in 2013 both species were proposed for listing as endangered under the federal Endangered Species Act.
How did this happen? Extensive research identifies two main reasons for their decline. First, trout were introduced in high-elevation lakes to draw recreationists and tourists to the area. This created an imbalance in the natural world. Trout eat tadpoles and small frogs and compete with frogs for insects. In addition, trout restrict frogs and tadpoles to small, low-quality areas and separate frog populations from one another. As a result, many mountain yellow-legged frog populations have died out. In addition, a fungal disease called chytridiomycosis is threatening the existence of frog populations that had once thrived in fishless areas. The disease affects the skin of frogs and causes most infected animals to die.
As the famous conservationist John Muir once said, "When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the Universe." Frogs are a very important link in the food chain, or the order in which animals feed upon other plants and animals. For example, the sun provides food for grass. The grass is eaten by a grasshopper. The grasshopper is eaten by a frog. The frog is eaten by a snake, and the snake is eaten by a hawk. Removing the frog from the food chain, if eaten by trout, limits food for other animals and disrupts the natural cycle.
Studies in the parks show that introduced trout harm entire ecosystems, not just mountain yellow-legged frogs. Trout are effective hunters who eat other amphibians, aquatic insects and zooplankton (small animals that naturally drift in water) leaving less food available for other wildlife.
With a helping hand, the mountain yellow-legged frogs staged an impressive recovery. In 2001, park staff began using large nets and electrofishers (a device that temporarily stuns fish) to physically remove trout from selected waters. The goal was to restore the balance of nature to the pre-trout environment, with a focus on improving the health of mountain yellow-legged frogs. By 2011, nearly 44,000 fish were removed from 19 lakes, including complete removal from 9 lakes.
In one restoration area, in remote lakes and streams of Upper LeConte Canyon, frog surveys conducted by park staff each summer season recorded the stunning progress. View LeConte restoration area map. From 2001, when fish removal began, to 2004, after most of the fish had been removed, the number of mountain yellow-legged frogs/tadpoles in three restoration lakes increased from nearly 190 to over 18,800 - a 10,000% increase! From 2005 to 2011, during the removal of the remaining few fish, the population of frogs/tadpoles in these lakes stabilized, with numbers ranging from a 1,900-6,000% increase. View mountain yellow-legged frog response graph. In addition, over 2,000 frogs moved into two nearby lakes. As a result, the frog population increased to the point where it is now in a much stronger position to deal with other threats, such as disease.
Due to these efforts, the natural balance has been restored for this population of mountain yellow-legged frogs. Hardy hikers in Upper LeConte Canyon may see many frogs or hear frequent "plops" or splashes near lakes and streams in summer. Other visitors may observe frogs laying eggs, see thousands of tadpoles as the waters warm, or learn about the project through park staff near the restoration areas. In addition, although introduced trout are being removed from selected waters to improve conditions for the parks' wildlife, trout will remain in hundreds of lakes and ponds in the parks, and ample opportunities will continue to be available for recreational fishing.
If you have been inspired by this story of the mountain yellow-legged frogs, you may be interested in the related plan and draft environmental impact statement that would potentially restore additional sites in the parks. For more information, be sure to visitRestoration of Native Species in High Elevation Aquatic Ecosystems. To add your name to the project mailing list, pleasesend an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org.