Person

David Thayer

Side profile portrait of a middle-aged man with dark hair, a beard, and wearing a three-piece suit.
Dr. David Thayer

Harvard Center for the History of Medicine. Courtesy of the Boston Medical Library

Quick Facts
Significance:
Doctor, State Legislator, Abolitionist
Place of Birth:
Braintree, Massachusetts
Date of Birth:
July 19, 1813
Place of Death:
Boston, Massachusetts
Date of Death:
December 13, 1893
Place of Burial:
Braintree, Massachusetts
Cemetery Name:
Plain Street Cemetery

Throughout his life, Dr. David Thayer committed himself to public causes. He participated in antislavery work, practiced as a homeopathic doctor, and served in the Massachusetts State Legislature as well as the Boston Vigilance Committee.

Born in Braintree, Massachusetts, David Thayer came from a family with ties to the earliest settlers in the area. Available records do not shed light on the first decades of Thayer's life.

In the 1830s, Thayer began studying at the Phillips' Academy in Andover. This time likely influenced his interest in antislavery. In 1834, students attempted to form their own antislavery society, which the principal rejected. After English antislavery activist George Thompson gave lectures in town the following January, the students decided to form an unsanctioned society. In response, the school's leadership established laws preventing students from participating in any antislavery society. Along with dozens of his fellow students, Thayer left the school.1 In a statement published in an abolitionist newspaper The Liberator, the students said they:

dissolve our connection with Phillips' Academy, because, under the existing administration of its laws, its members are not allowed in any manner to bring their influence...in an associated capacity, to bear upon a most wicked and odious system of fraud and oppression.2

Thayer completed his schooling in New Hampshire. He then attended Union College (graduated 1836) and Berkshire Medical School (graduated 1843). Dr. Thayer set up a practice in Boston the following year.3

While practicing, Dr. Thayer continued his activity in the abolitionist movement. He supported several antislavery organizations and attended events. Thayer most notably proposed a resolution at an 1843 Braintree meeting in support of George Latimer, declaring "it is the natural right of every human being to escape from slavery."4 Abolitionist Austin Bearse recorded Thayer's name as a member in the 1850 Boston Vigilance Committee.5 According to his obituary, Thayer also housed freedom seekers in his home and supported both William Lloyd Garrison and John Brown.6

Thayer's personal life remains mostly a mystery. According to available records, he married Susan C. Bliss on May 16, 1860.7

From 1855 to 1856, and later in 1865 and 1867, Dr. Thayer served in the Massachusetts State House of Representatives for Suffolk County. Among his responsibilities, Representative Thayer served as Chair of the Joint Standing Committee on Public Charitable Institutions. In this position, he helped secure funding for the Rainsford Island Hospital, as well as garnered support for other state-run schools, almshouses, and hospitals.8

During his long career in medicine, Dr. Thayer became interested in homeopathy, or the use of alternative medicine. His interest led to a professional calling. Dr. Thayer opened the Boston Gymnastic Institute, joined the American Institute in Homeopathy (later serving as president in 1870), and helped form the Massachusetts Homeopathic Medical Society and the Homeopathic Hospital in Boston.9

Giving a speech to the Massachusetts Homeopathic Medical Society in 1870, Thayer outlined the qualities of a "good physician:"

a man of keen insight, a faithful and studious observer, and a candid pupil of nature, an independent thinker, brave to meet danger, cool in moments of unexpected difficulty, an honorable man, a true and active friend and a loyal comrade.10

In this speech, Dr. Thayer also defended women's role in medicine, calling for their more welcome inclusion in the medical field.11

Dr. Thayer faced professional criticism for his work in the field of homeopathy. In 1871, he and some colleagues became the subject of a trial with the Massachusetts Medical Society. Two years later, a trial committee found him and his colleagues guilty of "conduct unbecoming unworthy an honorable physician by practising [sic] homoeopathy."12

Despite this expulsion, Dr. Thayer continued to practice and support health and social causes. At age 80, Dr. Thayer passed away on December 13, 1893, in Boston.13 At his funeral, Rev. M. J. Savage described him as "a man of convictions, and it was rare to find a man who had conviction and was willing to pay the price of popularity for them."14

Footnotes:

  1. "Extract of a Letter Dated Andover, Jan. 19 1835," The Liberator, February 07, 1835; "A Statement of the Circumstances which induced Fifty Students of Phillips' Academy, Andover, to ask a Dismission from that Institution," The Liberator, August 15, 1835. 
  2. "Extract of a Letter Dated Andover, Jan. 19 1835," The Liberator, February 07, 1835; "A Statement of the Circumstances which induced Fifty Students of Phillips' Academy, Andover, to ask a Dismission from that Institution," The Liberator, August 15, 1835.
  3. "Was a Pioneer Abolitionist. David Thayer, an Old Boston Physician, Dead," The Boston Herald, December 15, 1893.
  4. "A Voice from Old Braintree," The Liberator, January 13, 1843.
  5. "Was a Pioneer Abolitionist. David Thayer, an Old Boston Physician, Dead," The Boston Herald, December 15, 1893; Austin Bearse, Reminiscences of Fugitive-Slave Law Days in Boston (Boston: Warren Richardson, 1880).
  6. "Was a Pioneer Abolitionist. David Thayer, an Old Boston Physician, Dead," Boston Herald, December 15, 1893; Bearse, Reminiscences of Fugitive-Slave Law Days in Boston (Boston: Warren Richardson, 1880).
  7. New England Historic Genealogical Society; Boston, Massachusetts; Massachusetts Vital Records, 1911–1915.
  8. 1856 Senate Bill 0240. Report Of The Joint Standing Committee On Public Charitable Institutions Regarding Charitable Institutions Of The Commonwealth.1856 House Bill 0195. Resolve In Aid Of The State Hospitals At Rainsford Island And Taunton.
  9. "Was a Pioneer Abolitionist. David Thayer, an Old Boston Physician, Dead,"  Boston Herald, December 15, 1893.
  10. David Thayer, "The Coming Doctor: Annual Address Before the Mass. Homoeopathic Medical Society, 1870" (Taunton, MA: C.A. Hack and Son, 1875), 11.
  11. Thayer slides in a note of support for women's political rights: "I am too frank, and too loyal to the great civilizing forces of society, not to confess in passing that I think she has rights and duties in politics. Further, with great questions of vital interest impending, my judgement is that we cannot afford to excuse woman from her fair share of responsibility in these matters." (13).
  12. "The Homoeopaths Expelled," Boston Evening Transcript, May 24, 1873.
  13. New England Historic Genealogical Society; Boston, Massachusetts; Massachusetts Vital Records, 1840–1911. Massachusetts, U.S., Death Records, 1841-1915 - Ancestry.com
  14. "Funeral of Dr. David Thayer," Boston Herald, December 17, 1893. 

Boston African American National Historic Site

Last updated: November 2, 2026