Chapter 6:
The CCC: Accomplishments and Demise
It was just nine years and three months after the
creation of the Civilian Conservation Corps on March 31, 1933, that the
corps ceased active operation. The final decision to liquidate the CCC
was made on June 30, 1942, when Congress enacted the Labor-Federal
Security Administration Appropriation Act for the fiscal year 1943.
Enacting that supply bill, Congress voted to terminate the CCC and set
aside eight million dollars to defray the cost of liquidation. As soon
as the bill was signed by the president, directives went out to the
Departments of the Interior, Agriculture, and War, and to the Veterans'
Administration to proceed as rapidly as possible and complete the
process by July 1, 1943. All during the fiscal year 1942 the CCC had
been cut back; camps were abandoned when the jobs begun earlier were
completed. By the close of the fiscal year, June 30, 1942, there were
only about 350 camps left in operation.
But the CCC was still in charge of some 1,400 closed
camps, each containing an average of 20 buildings. It also owned over
35,000 pieces of automotive equipment, mostly trucks and tractors, and
vast quantities of other materials including large stocks of woolens,
cotton, foodstuffs, portable buildings, motor equipment, replacement
parts, tiresin fact nearly everything needed to run a program the
size of the CCC. The congressional act that terminated the CCC
stipulated that the War Department, the Navy Department, and the Civil
Aeronautics Administration had first choice of all CCC properties and
materials. The worst part of the liquidation process was that the men
who were in charge of all this equipment and material were leaving so
rapidly. The armed services were organizing and expanding for the war
effort, and many of the CCC men were answering the call to duty. Not
only were the officers being recalled from their assignments as camp
commanders, but many of the technical work supervisors were being
offered commissions. The CCC boys who had been well trained in
automotive equipment were, upon entering the services, made specialists
in the noncommissioned ranks.
Some time in December, 1941, in response to a request
from the military, the CCC director approved assigning national-defense
projects to camps on military reservations. By the first of the year 70
of the camps assigned to the various technical agencies either had
relocated on military reservations or had their manpower there. The
technical agencies continued to perform management functions in order to
relieve the military of that additional work. Later the director, with
the approval of the president, established a CCC victory war program
whereby all CCC agencies cooperated with the army in every way possible.
By the end of May, 1942, there were approximately 175 camps located on
military reservations, and by late June the CCC was devoted completely
to war-related projects. Whole camp companies and their heavy equipment
were taken over by the army and sent to Canada and Alaska to work on
construction of the Alcan Highway. Later the secretary of war publicly
complimented the CCC on the part it played in the prosecution of the war
effort, stating that the enrollees were "hardened physically, have
learned to live together as a Company in barracks, have respect for
authority, and are potential soldiers of high caliber."
Thus ended one of the great conservation programs in
the history of the United States. The National Park Service had directed
the work programs of CCC camps on areas administered by the service; it
also had been in charge of recreation-oriented camps on Tennessee Valley
Authority lands, in state, county, and metropolitan parks throughout the
continental United States, and in Hawaii and the Virgin Islands. The
work projects were designed primarily to protect and conserve
exceptional natural resources and to develop park and recreation areas
for public benefit.
During the entire period of the programfrom
April, 1933, through June, 1942work was undertaken by the National
Park Service on a total of 655 parks and related types of recreation
areas, broken down as follows: national park areas, 71; recreational
demonstration areas, 23; TVA areas, 8; federal defense areas, 29; state
parks, 405; county parks, 42; metropolitan parks, 75; and 2 areas not
classified above, on the West Point Military Academy reservation, in
New York, and on Battery Cove Federal Reservation, in Virginia. The
service supervised a total of approximately 3,350 camp years, or some
580,000 man years (including camp foremen) of work. Of this work about
25 per cent was on National Park Service areas and 75 per cent on other
park and recreation areas. At the peak of the program, in 1935, there
were 115 camps assigned to national park areas and 475 to other
areas.
In the following table are statistics on a few of the
types of work projects undertaken by the CCC from 1933 to 1943.
|
Item | Unit |
National Parks | State Parks and Related Areas |
Total |
|
Bathhouses | Number | 13 | 152 | 165 |
Cabins | Number | 14 | 1,463 | 1,477 |
Large dams | Number | 0 | 197 | 197 |
Telephone lines | Miles | 1,850 | 1,707 | 3,557 |
Water lines | Miles | 188 | 635 | 823 |
Roads and truck trails | Miles | 2,186 | 5,246 | 7,432 |
Campground development | Acres | 5,310 | 11,587 | 16,897 |
Picnic ground development | Acres | 404 | 5,370 | 5,774 |
Fighting forest fires | Man days | 250,000 | 408,276 | 658,276 |
Fire presuppression | Man days | 414,000 | 436,823 | 850,823 |
|
The amount of money expended by the service totaled
$130,504,000. It must be kept in mind, however, that the overhead
expenditures reflected only about 25 per cent of the total, because
housing, feeding, medical care, clothing, and education of the enrollees
and army officers' salaries were expenditures paid from CCC funds
allotted to the army. Consequently, the total expenditures for camps
under National Park Service supervision amounted to approximately
$467,100,000. Of this amount, $132,100,000 went to camps on national
park system properties; the balance of $335,000,000 went to camps
working on state and metropolitan parks and other recreation areas under
National Park Service supervision.
Cost of the CCC for the Fiscal Year 1939
|
Agency | Funds |
% of Total | Camps |
Director's Office | $237,319 | .07 | 1,500* |
War Department | 215,173,270 | 77.40 | 1,500* |
Interior Department | 18,492,645 | 6.70 | 450 |
Agriculture Department | 43,905,114 | 15,80 | 1,050 |
Labor Department | 30,567} |
| 1,500* |
Commerce Department | 26,691} | .03 | 1,500* |
Public Health Service | 29,781}
|
| 1,500*
|
Total | $277,895,477 | 100 | 1,500 |
*These agencies provided services to all camps.
|
How much did the CCC program cost, and how many boys
went through the CCC? On the basis of the CCC director's report for one
fiscal year, 1939, I'll try to give a reasonable answer.
The average daily strength of the camps for fiscal
year 1939 was 156 boys, giving a total strength of 234,000 boys (156 x
1,500). The table on page 127 shows a total of 16,935 camp years, or
203,220 camp months, for the entire CCC program. The records show that
the average enrollment of a CCC boy was nine months, and the overall
average number of enrollees per camp was 160. So, by dividing the
203,220 camp months by 9 x 160, we find that the total enrollment was in
the neighborhood of 3,612,800 men. My records show the total cost to be
around $2,780,000,000 or about $770 per average nine-month enrollee, or
$1,025 per enrollment year. The actual cost in the beginning was a
little less than $900 per enrollee year, but by the time the program was
closing out the cost was in the neighborhood of $1,400 per enrollment
year.
On June 30, 1942, the Department of the Interior was
operating 114 active CCC camps in the continental United States, in
addition to 41 CCC projects on 80 Indian reservations and camps in
Hawaii and the Virgin Islands, and had on hand approximately $17 million
worth of construction and other operating equipment. The closing of
camps involved leaving the unfinished work projects in the best possible
shape; terminating around 1,800 employees; transferring CCC property to
the army, navy, and other agencies; and preparing final accountability
records. By June 30, 1943, the liquidation of the CCC was virtually
completed. The Interior Department had approximately $1.5 million left
of the $8 million appropriated for terminating the program. In order to
take care of the final stages of CCC liquidation, Congress appropriated
$20,000 to the Federal Security Agency for the 1944 fiscal year. No
funds from this appropriation were alloted to the Department of the
Interior. I informed the secretary that there was still work to be done
and that I was planning to continue discharging the duties of
departmental representative until June 30, 1944, but would submit my
final report on the interior CCC program by January, 1944.
Cost Per Camp and Enrollee, Fiscal Year 1939
|
Agency | Per Camp | Per Enrollee |
|
Army | $143,450 | $920.00 |
Interior Department Agriculture Department | 41,454 | 266.00 |
Director and others | 216
| 1.40
|
| $185,120 | $1,187.40 |
|
Included in my report was a statement of the
accomplishments of the CCC camps prepared by each bureau of the
department that had camps assigned to it, and all the bureaus preferred
to tell in their own way the accomplishments of their camps. Although
the statements of the several bureaus are not included here, the tables
on pages 148 and 149 show the extent of their participation and how the
distribution of camps in the Interior Department compared with that in
the Agriculture Department.
Civilian Conservation Corps, Department of the
InteriorNumber of Appointive Personnel Employed
|
| Bureau of Reclamation |
Fish and Wildlife Service1 |
General Land Office |
Grazing Service |
National Park Service |
Office of Indian Affairs |
|
On June 30: |
1933 | -- | -- | 9 |
-- | 44+ | -- |
1934 | -- | -- | 14 |
-- | 4,731 | 829 |
1935 | 50 | -- | 14 |
98 | 7,031 | 1,180 |
1936 | 227 | -- | 25 |
601 | 5,890 | 986 |
1937 | 284 | -- | 27 |
600 | 6,203 | 806 |
1938 | 295 | -- | 18 |
631 | 4,303 | 782 |
1939 | 346 | 463 | 50 |
889 | 3,506 | 609 |
1940 | 362 | 387 | 67 |
950 | 3,400 | 646 |
1941 | 379 | 369 | 62 |
898 | 3,228 | 613 |
1942 | 155 | 209 | 44 |
305 | 1,219 | 534 |
1943 | -- | -- | 1 |
-- | 30 | 5 |
1Does not include employees on CCC rolls
prior to consolidation of the Bureau of Biological Survey of the
Department of Agriculture with the Bureau of Fisheries of the Department
of Commerce to form the Fish and wildlife Service, and its transfer to
the Department of the Interior.
|
Civilian Conservation Corps, Department of the
InteriorTotal Camp Months of CCC Operations
|
Fiscal year |
Bureau of Reclamation |
Fish and Wildlife Service1 |
General Land Service |
Grazing Service |
National Park Service2 |
Office of Indian Affairs |
1933 | -- | -- | 1 |
-- | 99 | -- |
1934 | -- | -- | 12 |
| 3,274 | 804 |
1935 | 83 | -- | 12 |
| 5,184 | 900 |
1936 | 377 | -- | 22 |
| 5,928 | 852 |
1937 | 431 | -- | 24 |
| 5,210 | 792 |
1938 | 449 | -- | 16 |
| 3,981 | 828 |
1939 | 527 | 63 | 60 |
| 3,822 | 840 |
1940 | 555 | 408 | 69 |
| 3,832 | 852 |
1941 | 550 | 433 | 72 |
| 3,769 | 852 |
1942 | 372
| 325
| 48
|
| 2,268
| 840
|
Total | 3,344 | 1,229 | 336 |
| 37,367 | 7,560 |
1Does not include operations prior to consolidation of the
Bureau of Biological Survey of the Department of Agriculture with the
Bureau of Fisheries of the Department of Commerce to form the Fish and
Wildlife Service, and its transfer to the Department of the
Interior.
2Includes operations in Hawaii, Alaska, and the Virgin
Islands.
|
Distribution of Standard CCC Camps in Continental United States
|
CCC period |
Dates embraced by CCC period1 |
Bureau of Reclamation |
Fish and Wildlife Service2 |
General Land Office |
Grazing Service |
National Park Service |
Others under Interior Department |
Total Interior |
Total Agriculture |
Total others3 |
Grand total |
|
1 | June 1, 1933, to Sept. 30, 1933 |
-- | -- | 1 | -- |
172 | -- | 173 | 1,264 |
31 | 1,468 |
2 | Oct. 1, 1933, to Mar. 31, 1934 |
-- | -- | 1 | -- |
304 | -- | 305 | 1,128 |
35 | 1,468 |
3 | Apr. 1, 1934, to Sept. 30, 1934 |
8 | -- | 1 | -- |
428 | 434 | 471 | 1,135 |
34 | 1,640 |
4 | Oct. 1, 1934, to Mar. 31, 1935 |
9 | -- | 1 | -- |
429 | 451 | 490 | 1,125 |
24 | 1,640 |
5 | Apr. 1, 1935, to Sept. 30, 1935 |
30 | -- | 2 | 31 |
561 | -- | 624 | 1,907 |
104 | 2,635 |
6 | Oct. 1,1935, to Mar. 31, 1936 |
37 | -- | 2 | 45 |
489 | -- | 573 | 1,751 |
103 | 2,427 |
7 | Apr. 1,1936, to Sept. 30, 1936 |
34 | -- | 2 | 45 |
430 | -- | 511 | 1,524 |
76 | 2,111 |
8 | Oct. 1, 1936, to Mar. 31, 1937 |
34 | -- | 2 | 45 |
426 | -- | 507 | 1,505 |
78 | 2,090 |
9 | Apr. 1, 1937, to Sept. 30, 1937 |
34 | -- | 2 | 45 |
379 | -- | 460 | 1,335 |
54 | 1,849 |
10 | Oct. 1, 1937, to Mar. 31, 1938 |
34 | -- | 1 | 45 |
320 | -- | 400 | 1,157 |
47 | 1,604 |
11 | Apr. 1,1938, to Sept. 30, 1938 |
40 | -- | 4 | 72 |
305 | -- | 421 | 1,073 |
6 | 1,500 |
12 | Oct. 1, 1938, to Mar. 31, 1939 |
42 | -- | 4 | 87 |
311 | -- | 444 | 1,056 |
-- | 1,500 |
13 | Apr. 1, 1939, to Sept. 30, 1939 |
44 | -- | 5 | 90 |
311 | -- | 450 | 1,050 |
-- | 1,500 |
14 | Oct. 1, 1939, to Mar. 31, 1940 |
44 | 34 | 6 | 91 |
310 | -- | 485 | 1,015 |
| 1,500 |
15 | Apr. 1,1940, to Sept. 30, 1940 |
44 | 36 | 6 | 89 |
310 | -- | 485 | 1,012 |
3 | 1,500 |
16 | Oct. 1,1940, to Mar. 31, 1941 |
44 | 36 | 6 | 89 |
308 | -- | 483 | 1,008 |
9 | 1,500 |
17 | Apr. 1, 1941, to Sept. 30, 1941 |
36 | 29 | 4 | 53 |
223 | 523 | 368 | 6307 |
5 | 1,103 |
18 | Oct. 1, 1941, to Mar. 31, 1942 |
26 | 20 | 4 | 34 |
78 | 536 | 198 | 7397 |
5 | 600 |
19 | Apr. 1, 1942, to June 30, 1942 |
7 | 5 | 3 | 3 |
39 | 557 | 114 | 8250 |
5 | 369 |
|
1In some instances program changed within the period.
2Prior to 14th period, the Bureau of Biological Survey, (now
integrated with the Fish and wildlife Service) received camps under
quota of the Department of Agriculture.
3Army and Navy.
4Soil Erosion Service.
5National Defense.
6Includes 27 on National Defense.
7Includes 55 on National Defense.
8Includes 92 on National Defense.
NOTE. Office of Indian Affairs not included because its camps
were not standard-type camps.
|