CHAPTER SIX:
Historical Accuracy vs Good Taste: Valley
Forge in the 1920s and 1930s (continued)
The key issue underlying the years of conflict
between Dr. Burk and some of the park commissioners was whether the park
would swallow up what was left of the two communities of Port Kennedy
and Valley Forge and all the territory between them, transforming the
area according to their conception of the eighteenth-century Valley
Forge and necessarily quashing Burk's plans for the cathedral. By the
mid-1920s, park commissioners were aware that builders were planning
residential communities at Valley Forge like the one called "Valley
Forge Manor" touted in a brochure as a "sportsman's paradise" and an
"ideal home community." [82] The park
commission used such schemes to justify additional condemnations in the
area of Valley Forge village, warning that building developments would
"destroy with commonplace houses the natural and beautiful surrounds and
make forever impossible the preservation of what now can be preserved."
[83] Pennypacker expanded on this statement,
speaking of "the menace of bungalow development, of booze parties, of a
litter of cans and refuse." [84] By the
late 1920s the park commissioners sought sizable appropriations with the
objective of new expansion for the park.
As a park commissioner, Burk was consistent in his
opposition to park expansion plans. At one point he asked that his vote
against plans of the park commission's Land Committee be recorded in the
minutes because, he said, their program was "unhistorical and unsocial."
[85] He could not see why the park should
be any bigger than the winter encampment appeared to have been according
to then available documents. He expressed this opinion in a pamphlet
titled "What Shall We Do With Valley Forge?" which he personally
distributed to members of the state legislature in Harrisburg.
Washington, Burk wrote, "never placed any of his men in a swamp. Yet a
swamp, filled in with cinders, was part of the ground purchased for
Valley Forge Park." Burk came close to making charges of graft with the
words "Shall [Valley Forge] become a thin excuse for a raid upon the
treasury of the Commonwealth, or shall it be kept as a sacred trust for
the Nation?" [86] The park's planned
expansion led to Burk's resignation from the park commission early in
1929.
Burk faced his greatest challenge from the park
commission later that year when the park commissioners voted on whether
to condemn the very land he had already purchased for his cathedral and
where he had erected its cornerstone. Park commissioners were divided on
the issue, 6 voting yea and 6 voting nay. This meant that the resolution
did not pass, and Burk expressed his gratitude in a sermon titled
"Valley Forge Miracles," in which he thanked his saviors by claiming,
"They stood out against the enemies of religion and patriotism." He went
on to state that all the land connected with the Washington Memorial was
dedicated to the American people and that "only eyes blinded by
jealousy, greed and bigotry have failed to see this." [87] Around the same time, Burk found himself
fighting a more personal battle when the park commission condemned
property belonging to his wife plus another parcel owned by Frank Quigg,
a member of his vestry. The park commission did not object when a jury
of view awarded more for these properties than they wanted to pay. [88] Settlements were made, and by the end of
1931 structures on these two properties were razed. [89]
The same year, conflict arose over who would get to
host President Herbert Hoover at Valley Forge: the park commission or
Dr. Burk. Roosevelt's 1904 visit had attracted a good deal of attention
for Burk's little chapel, and in 1921 President Harding had visited the
Washington Memorial where he spoke at the dedication of the Rhode Island
bay in the cloister. In 1929, the Valley Forge Historical Society voted
to make President Hoover an Honorary Perpetual Life Benefactor of the
society and invited him to visit the Washington Memorial to receive this
honor. [90] In the spring of 1931, while
President Hoover was actually planning such a visit to Valley Forge, the
park commission voted to invite him to inspect Washington's Headquarters
while he was in the area. [91] Somehow the
President changed his plans, and his visit to the Washington Memorial
became a visit to the park.
Israel Pennypacker was delighted to receive the
President's acceptance and the news that Hoover would deliver a Memorial
Day address at Valley Forge. [92] In
preparation for the visit, the park commission erected a platform near
the farmhouse now known as Huntington's Quarters, literally across the
road from the Washington Memorial, and furnished a parlor there for the
President's use. [93] Burk complained, "The
Valley Forge Park Commission has found some way to have it act as his
host in spite of the fact that he is an Honorary Perpetual Benefactor of
our Society and was to have received his gold insignia here on Memorial
Day." [94] The final insult came when Burk
received a letter from a park commission member saying that officials in
Washington had already been assured that he would not even ring the
church bells at the Washington Memorial before and after the President's
speech, as he had been planning to do. [95]
A special train brought President Hoover to Valley
Forge, and a motorcade conducted him along Outer Line Drive to the
National Memorial Arch and finally to the speaker's platform. The
President's speech remains one of the strongest and best ever delivered
at Valley Forge, skillfully linking the Valley Forge experience to
America's then very depressed economy. "The American people are going
through another Valley Forge at this time," he said. "To each and every
one of us it is an hour of unusual stress and trial." Stressing a point
he would make many times in his administration, Hoover observed that
there were no panaceas, and that the American people did not
collectively owe each individual a living. At Valley Forge, Washington
and his men too might have surrendered to despair, but chose instead to
conserve their strength and husband their resources. Similarly, America
now depended on "the inventiveness, the resourcefulness and the
initiative of every one of us. . . . God grant that we may prove worthy
of George Washington and his men of Valley Forge." [96] Dr. Burk did not have a seat on the
speakers' platform, and the invocation that day was delivered by the
Episcopal bishop, the Rt. Rev. Francis M. Tait. Before the President
departed, however, Burk did manage to present him with a bouquet of
thirty red roses, which was enough to get his own name in the news. [97]
The American people would survive the depression, but
Burk did not. He died on June 30, 1933, and was buried in the churchyard
behind the Washington Memorial. The president of the American Friends of
Lafayette condoled the officers of the Valley Forge Historical Society
with the words "It is a distinct loss to those who are interested in
keeping alive the traditions of our Country, when a real enthusiast
falls out of the ranks." [98] Burk's
cathedral essentially died with him. The few physical remains of his
ambitious plans include the cornerstone now hidden by thick undergrowth
in a wooded area of the Washington Memorial property, and a statue Burk
intended for cathedral decoration.
In 1931, Burk had obtained permission from the
governor of Virginia to make a bronze cast of the famous statue of
Washington by Jean Antoine Houdon in the state capitol at Richmond. Burk
had hoped that President Hoover would dedicate it during his visit to
Valley Forge that spring another dream that never came true. [99] This statue was still standing at the
cathedral site in the 1940s when the park commissioners considered
acquiring their own statue of Washington for the park but doubted that
funds could be secured for this purpose. [100] Burk's statue apparently fell into park
hands when the commissioners purchased a few acres of Washington
Memorial land. [101] It was placed at
Huntington's Quarters, but in 1957 plans were made to move it to
Washington's Headquarters, where it was mounted on a base and
attractively landscaped and considered quite tasteful, until it was
removed in the interests of historical accuracy. It is now in the park's
Visitor Center.

Fig. 17. Valley Forge's replica of Jean
Antoine Houdon's statue of George Washington. Burk hoped it would adorn
the cathedral he planned for Valley Forge. For a number of years, the
statue was placed outside Washington's Headquarters. Today, it is
located in the Visitor Center. (Courtesy, Valley Forge National
Historical Park)
|
Until his death, Burk optimistically continued
collecting artifacts and hoping to expand his museum operations. In
1930, the volunteer firemen of Pennsylvania were raising money for a
museum of fire-fighting apparatus, to be located on the Washington
Memorial grounds. [102] The following
year, the historical society purchased another of its treasures, the
1883 painting titled Washington Reviewing His Troops at Valley
Forge by W. T. Trego. The directors of the society, however, soon
felt the effects of the depression and had to call special meetings to
determine what could be done when people began neglecting to pay their
membership dues, causing debts to mount. A few months after Burk's
death, the society sent a form letter asking recipients to donate money
for coal to heat the museum. [103] As the
difficult 1930s continued, without the enthusiasm and leadership of Dr.
Burk, collecting virtually ceased. In 1938, the historical society
reported a lack of funds for the purchase of artifacts, "owing largely
to the depression." [104]
Burk did live long enough to see the demise of the
expansion plans proposed for the park between 1927 and 1929. In the
summer of 1929, Pennsylvania's governor informed the park commission
that no funds were available for extending the park, [105] and they were not forthcoming two years
later when the park commission sought $100,000 to purchase land. [106] As a result, the Land Committee
considered raising its own funds "from the general public for the
acquisition of land needed for the proper completion of the park." [107] They even took a lesson from Dr. Burk,
contemplating the sale of certificates to public school students. [108] But neither scheme was carried out.
Dr. Burk also lived long enough to see his old enemy,
Israel Pennypacker, removed from the park commission. When Governor
Gifford Pinchot took office, he decided to purge the appointed officials
and state employees he had inherited from the previous administration of
rival Republicans. Early in 1932, members of the park commission got
letters asking them to continue to serve but demanding that they sign a
loyalty pledge to the governors platform. Most refused, and Governor
Pinchot named newcomers to the park commission. Pennypacker later
lamented those who had been replaced, describing them as "a number of
the most interested, best informed and most diligent of the members of
the Commission." [109]
By the end of the transition period of the 1920s and
1930s, the evolution thus far of Valley Forge as a historic site had
created a strangely eclectic landscape. In a 1936 book called The
Blue Hills, Cornelius Weygandt wrote:
The hills of Valley Forge were far more beautiful in
my youth than they are to-day. Then there was no intrusion of a Gothic
church, of an architecture alien to eighteenth century America; and then
the countryside was still a typical stretch of Pennsylvania farm
country. Now large portions of the park look like a cemetery without
graves. Gettysburg has been preserved as Pennsylvania farm country.
Valley Forge has suffered the indignity of being transformed into a
"park." [110]
Unknown to the author, the park commission was
formulating plans that would transform it even more.

Fig. 18. Dr. Burk's grave, behind the
Washington Memorial Chapel. The marker lists his many
accomplishments.
|
|