Johnson/Anderson Fishery

On This Page Navigation

two fishhouses side by side with three boats in front and the left house's door open
Emil Anderson Fish House and Dock (Building #305), 1950s.

National Visual Inventory Cards 50-1093


Duluth fishermen Herman Johnson and John Anderson established a commercial fishing business at present day Belle Isle around 1890. Johnson and Anderson were squatting and never held title to the property. Eventually the land was purchased by Belle Isle Resort owner Fred Schofield. Believing he also held title to Johnson Island, Schofield granted the pair permission to relocate their operations across the harbor. Johnson and Anderson would later purchase the island.(Gale, 1995)

Johnson Island, a five-acre island in Belle Harbor, has been called Fish Island, Bell Island, and Emil Anderson's. It lies east of Belle Isle campground where John Anderson and his partner Herman Johnson established their original fish camp. The fish camp includes the island, Belle Isle, and the waters between them. Johnson Island is not particularly impressive by itself but the surrounding area is clustered with islands similar to it. There are many bays, coves, channels, and reefs, and the area as a whole provides good shelter and anchorage. In the surrounding area, they hunted, fished, and gathered plants such as thimbleberries, raspberries, and blueberries. Occasionally, 4th of July celebrations were held but more often the Anderson family traveled to Tobin Harbor for the festivities there.(Toupal et. al, 2002)

While several fishermen fished the waters associated with Johnson Island, only the John Anderson and Herman Johnson families lived there. Anderson and Johnson fished the area from the 1880s to 1922 when Herman died. John's son, Gilbert, fished the area with his partner, Thure Goss, from about 1915 to 1918 before they left to serve in World War I. Gilbert returned after the war to fish alone until 1933. Emil, his father, and Uncle Edward fished the area from 1933 to 1937. (Toupal et. al, 2002)

On January 31, 1938, Johnson Island was sold to the U.S. government in exchange for $768.62 and a life lease. When John died, Emil and Edward continued fishing until Edward's passing in 1941. Emil continued fishing with his son and several hired hands until he retired in 1958. Surviving structures include the main residence, a fish house, and a log cabin. James and Mary Anderson are the only children elligible for a Special Use Permit.

(Toupal et. al, 2002)

Fishery Site

map of Johnson-Anderson fishery site containing 2 cabins, a house, an old privy, a log cabin, and 3 docks
Johnson Island Fishery Site Map, 2014


Isle Royale National Park

Last updated: September 11, 2020