Place

Cowpens Audio Tour Stop 13: Howard's Misunderstood Order

way side with a paved path on the left and trees in the background.
Colonel Howards Misunderstood Order way side

NPS Photo / Mike Puckett

Lt. Col. John Eager Howard’s Continentals stood their ground and held fast when Tarleton’s infantry attacked them on this spot on the battlefield. With his infantry advance stopped dead in its tracks, Lt. Col. Tarleton called upon his elite reserve troops to turn the tide of the battle. Tarleton wrote later saying he,“thought the advance of the 71st into line, and a movement of the cavalry in reserve to threaten the enemies right flank, would put a victorious period to the action.”

Led by Cpt. Ogilive’s Legion Cavalry, Major Archibald MacArthur of the 71st Highlanders advanced his nearly 300 men to join the action on the American right. With the bagpipes belting out a sweetly, haunting tune, the Scotsmen were hard to miss as they confidently advanced into line.

Lt. Col. Howard certainly did not miss the approach of the 71st. He countered MacArthur’s flank attack by ordering the Virginians on the far right of the line to contest their advance. The 150, or so, Virginians were ordered to refuse the right flank. This meant the troops were to wheel backward and form a right angle to better oppose the 71st Highlanders.

For reasons still unclear to this day, the Virginia troops misunderstood the order. With the American line in a state of confusion, the 71st Highlanders fired a volley that further eroded the Virginian’s position. The Virginians began an unexpected, yet orderly withdrawal from the main American battleline.

Lt. Col. Howard immediately recognized the dangerous and potentially catastrophic situation. Now, outflanked by the 71st and with pressure building on his immediate front, Howard ordered the Continentals to redeploy to the high ground in their rear.

The line fell back about 80 to 100 yards, with the right-side troops making better time than the troops on the left which caused the line to bow a bit. General Morgan arrived at Howard’s line just as the troops were redeploying and shouted his great concern to Howard about his retreat. Howard responded, saying,“…I pointed to the line and observing that men were not beaten who retreated in that order.”

The misunderstood order turned out to be the lucky break that the Americans needed. It allowed Howard’s troops to escape the Highlander’s flanking movement. The Americans halted on the high ground and turned to face the charging British. They delivered a point-blank volley into the startled British troops and counter attacked with their own bayonet charge, stopping and reversing the momentum of the fight.                        

Cowpens National Battlefield

Last updated: September 30, 2026