Chapter 1
EXPLORATIONS, IMPRESSIONS, AND EXCAVATIONS
The Prehistoric Ruins of the Verde Valley in the Nineteenth Century
Notes
1. Katharine Bartlett, "Notes upon
the Routes of Espejo and Farfan to the Mines in the Sixteenth Century,"
New Mexico Historical Review (January 1942): 2123; George
Peter Hammond and Agapito Rey, Expedition into New Mexico Made by
Antonio de Espejo, 15821583, As Revealed in the Journal of Diego
Pérez de Luxán, a Member of the Party (Los Angeles:
Quivira Society, 1929), 3638.
2. See
Bartlett, "Notes," for a summary of the speculations made by historians
Hubert Howe Bancroft, Herbert Eugene Bolton, George P. Hammond, and
Agapito Rey regarding Espejo's route. Bartlett makes a strong case that
Espejo and party traveled through the Verde Valley and provides detailed
notes illuminating Luxán's journals.
3. Hammond and Rey,
Expedition, 1056.
4. Herbert Eugene Bolton, Spanish
Exploration in the Southwest, 15421706 (New York: Charles
Scribner's Sons, 1916), 187. In this work, Bolton assembles a variety of
primary documents relating to Spanish explorations, including those of
Espejo, Farfán, and Oñate. This passage, written by
Espejo, describes a region with features similar to those of the Verde
Valley.
5. Bartlett, "Notes," 2835.
Bartlett's notes match Luxán's observations with existing
features of the Verde Valley.
6. Ibid., 3536.
7. For accounts of Oñate's
journey through the Verde Valley on the way to California, see Marc
Simmons, The Last Conquistador: Juan de Oñate and the Settling
of the Far Southwest (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991),
117275; and Bolton, Spanish Exploration, 26971.
8. For examples of recent research on
the Spanish and Mexican periods of Arizona history, see Simmons, The
Last Conquistador; James E. Officer, Hispanic Arizona,
15361856 (Tucson: University Press, 1987); David J. Weber,
The Spanish Frontier in North America (New Haven: Yale Univ.
Press, 1992); David J. Weber, The Mexican Frontier, 1821-1846: The
American Southwest under Mexico (Albuquerque: University of New
Mexico Press, 1982); John L. Kessel, Friars, Soldiers and Reformers:
Hispanic Arizona and the Sonora Mission Frontier, 1767-1856 (Tucson:
University of Arizona Press, 1976); Thomas E. Sheridan, Los
Tucsonenses: The Mexican Community in Tucson, 18541941
(Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1986); Thomas H. Naylor and
Charles W. Polzer, S.J., eds., The Presidio and Militia on the
Northern Frontier of New Spain: A Documentary History, Volume I,
1570-1700 (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1986); Charles W.
Polzer, S.J., and Thomas E. Sheridan, eds., The Presidio and Militia
on the Northern Frontier of New Spain: A Documentary History, Volume
2, Part I: The Californias and Sinaloa-Sonora, 17001765
(Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1997).
9. Robert Glass Cleland, This
Reckless Breed of Men: The Trappers and Fur Traders of the Southwest
(New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1950), 182.
10. Ibid., 228.
11. Lt. A. W. Whipple, "Report upon
the Indian Tribes," in Reports of Explorations and Surveys to
Ascertain the Most Practicable and Economical Route for a Railroad from
the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean 185354, vol. 3
(Washington, D.C.: A.O.P. Nicholson, 1856), 1415.
12. Ibid., 1415.
13. A. Berle Clemensen, A
Centennial History of the First Prehistoric Reserve, 18921992:
Administrative History of Casa Grande National Monument (Washington,
D.C.: National Park Service, 1992), 13.
14. Walter Hickling Prescott,
Conquest of Mexico (New York: Random House, 1843), 13.
15. "The Land of the Aztecs,"
Arizona Miner, 11 May 1864.
16. Arizona Miner, 25 May
1864, quoted in Pauline Henson, Founding a Wilderness Capital:
Prescott, A.T., 1864 (Flagstaff: Northland Press, 1965), 155.
17. Hubert Howe Bancroft, History
of Arizona and New Mexico, 15301888 (San Francisco: The
History Company, 1889), 45. The proliferation of such misnaming is
exemplified in Will C. Barnes, Arizona Place Names (Tucson:
University of Arizona Press, 1988), which lists a dozen Montezuma place
names. Susan Wallace, wife of the 1880s governor of New Mexico, offered
an apology for perpetuating the Montezuma myth by the frequent use of
the name in her book The Land of the Pueblos (New York: John B.
Alden, 1890). Although the repetition of the name seemed a glaring error
after Bancroft's strong opinion, Wallace kept the references to
Montezuma in her work because of the widespread familiarity and
association with the name.
18. Edmund Wells, Argonaut Tales:
Stories of the Gold Seekers and the Indian Scouts of Early Arizona
(New York: The Grafton Press, 1927), 396400.
19. For details of Woolsey's second
expedition, see John S. Goff, King S. Woolsey (Cave Creek: Black
Mountain Press, 1981), 4042.
20. Henry Clifton, "The Woolsey
Expedition," Arizona Miner, 25 May 1864.
21. The fact file at Montezuma
Castle National Monument contains the following information provided by
Mrs. Virginia Laudermilk in1946. She related an account that she
obtained from Edmund Wells regarding the naming of Montezuma Well. Wells
told her of a time when he was with a party from Fort Verde that was
pursuing a band of Apache, and they came upon a large well. "The
soldiers knew the Aztec Indians had attained a high plane of culture and
that Montezuma was once their chieftan [sic] so they facetiously
suggested the spring be called Montezuma's Well. Mrs. Laudermilk was
careful to point out that the word 'facetious' was used by Mr. Wells."
However, it seems that Wells arrived in the Camp Verde area around
186567, shortly after the events of Woolsey's second expedition.
Further, Wells's name does not appear on a list of members of the
Woolsey Party that was published in the 6 April 1864 edition of the
Arizona Miner. It could be that he heard the stories from the
Woolsey expedition of the naming of the Well and repeated them to Mrs.
Laudermilk. Wells also described the discovery and naming of Montezuma's
Castle by a small party, including himself, in his book Argonaut
Tales, 347. Yet because of the date of his arrival in the Verde
Valley, it seems doubtful that Wells was the first to come upon these
ruins and name them.
22. Thomas Edwin Farish, History
of Arizona, vol. 4 (San Francisco: Filmer Brothers Electrotype,
1916), 21517. The other members of this party were William L.
Osborn, Clayton M. Ralston, Henry D. Morse, Jake Ramstein, Thomas Ruff,
Ed A. Boblett, James Parrish, and James Robinson.
23. Stephen C. Shadegg, "Camp
Verde," Stephen C. Shadegg Collection, box 1, folder 6, Arizona
Historical Foundation, Tempe; Robert W. Munson, "Territorial Verde
Valley," Plateau 53 (1981): 2529.
24. Munson, "Territorial Verde
Valley," 2529.
25. Marvin D. Jeter, ed., Edward
Palmer's Arkansas Mounds (Fayetteville: University of Arkansas
Press, 1990), 3.
26. Marvin D. Jeter, "Edward Palmer:
Present before the Creation of Archaeological Stratigraphy and
Associations, Formation Processes, and Ethnographic Analogy," Journal
of the Southwest 41 (Autumn 1999), 336.
27. University of Arizona Library,
Special Collections, Edward Palmer Manuscript Collection, AZ 197, part
2. In an article published in 1871, Palmer describes details of the
corncob specimens he had retrieved from ruins in the Verde Valley. This
article reflects Palmer's pioneering work in the fields of ethnobotany
and archaeobotany. See Edward Palmer, "Food Products of the North
American Indians," U.S. Department of Agriculture Annual Report for
1870, 40428.
28. University of Arizona Library,
Special Collections, Edward Palmer Manuscript Collection, AZ 197, part
3.
29. Jeter, Edward Palmer's
Arkansas Mounds, 46.
30. University of Arizona Library,
Special Collections, Edward Palmer Manuscript Collection, AZ 197, parts
2 and 3.
31. Jeter, "Edward Palmer,"
33554.
32. Palmer, "Food Products of the
North American Indians," 420; Don D. Fowler and John F. Matley, The
Palmer Collection from Southwestern Utah, 1875, University of Utah
Anthropological Papers, No. 99 (Salt Lake City: University of Utah,
1978), 20.
33. Jeter, Edward Palmer's
Arkansas Mounds, 46.
34. University of Arizona Library,
Special Collections, Edward Palmer Manuscript Collection, AZ 197, part
2.
35. Jeter, Edward Palmer's
Arkansas Mounds, 4849.
36. Ibid.
37. Munson, "Territorial Verde
Valley," 2829.
38. John G. Bourke, On the Border
with Crook (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1891; reprint, Lincoln:
University of Nebraska Press, 1971), 149, 21012 (page references
are to reprint edition); The governor's visit to the ruins is described
in Wallace W. Elliott, History of Arizona Territory Showing Its
Resources and Advantages (San Francisco, 1884; reprint, Flagstaff:
Northland Press, 1964), 126 (page reference is to reprint edition).
39. "Curious Ancient Dwellings in
Arizona," The Friend, 43 (7 December 1869), 134.
40. Ibid.
41. William C. Manning, "Ancient
Pueblos of New Mexico and Arizona," Harper's New Monthly Magazine
51 (June 1875): 32729.
42. The map used in Richard J.
Hinton's 1878 Hand-book to Arizona: Its Resources, History, Towns,
Mines, Ruins, and Scenery (San Francisco: Payot, Uphan and Co.; New
York: American News Co., 1878), which shows the locations of ruins in
the area, was based on military maps of the time. Increasing military
presence in the valley led to more visitation to ruins sites by officers
and civilians alike.
43. For information on the history
of the ownership of Montezuma Well and surrounding area, see Pioneer
Stories of Arizona's Verde Valley (n.p.: Verde Valley Pioneers
Association, 1954), 68, 14748; Jack E. Beckman, "A History of
Montezuma Well" (unpublished manuscript), 1718; Til Lightbourn and
Mary Lyons, By the Banks of Beaver Creek (Nappanee, Indiana:
Evangel Press, 1989), 1718, 2224. The Montezuma Post Office
is listed in John Theobald and Lillian Theobald, Arizona Territory:
Post Offices and Postmasters, 1863 to 1912 (Phoenix: Arizona
Historical Foundation, 1961), 114.
44. Hodge's descriptions were
extensively copied by other writers, such as by California journalist
Richard J. Hinton in his Hand-book to Arizona (1878), 38283
and 41822, or abridged, as in Prescott editor Patrick Hamilton's
The Resources of Arizona (Prescott: n.p., 1881), 351, and in
The History of Arizona Territory (San Francisco; W.W. Elliot and
Co., 1884), 12526. The authors use the name Montezuma Well, but
refer to the cliff dwelling on Beaver Creek without using a name.
45. Hiram C. Hodge, Arizona As It
Is (New York: Hurd and Houghton, 1877); reprint, Arizona As It
Was (Chicago: The Rio Grande Press,1967), 19195 (page
references are to reprint edition).
46. Ibid., 24041.
47. William "Bucky" O. O'Neill,
Central Arizona: For Homes, for Health, for Wealth (Prescott:
Hoof and Horn, 1887), 9-11, 30-33, 120.
48. Walter J. Hoffman, "Ethnographic
Observations," in Tenth Annual Report of the United States Geological
and Geographical Survey of the Territories. Embracing Colorado and Parts
of Adjacent Territories (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing
Office, 1878), 47778.
49. Ibid., 47779.
50. Edgar Alexander Mearns, "Ancient
Dwellings of the Rio Verde Valley," The Popular Science Monthly
37 (October 1890): 751.
51. Ibid., 755.
52. Ibid., 75557. Mearns's
field notes and artifact collection from his Montezuma Castle
excavations are still housed at the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
53. Albert H. Schroeder to
Custodian, Tuzigoot National Monument, 25 December 1947, Tuzigoot
National Monument Fact File, Clarkdale, Arizona. Schroeder's memo was
based on information he gathered while looking through the notes and
collections made by Dr. Mearns in the Verde Valley in the 1880s, now
located in the American Museum of Natural History, New York.
54. The Tuzigoot site was next
investigated in 1933 when the Yavapai County Chamber of Commerce sought
prehistoric materials for display at the planned Smoki Museum in
Prescott. Earl Jackson originally proposed the Tuzigoot site, and the
excavation work was completed under the direction of Louis Caywood and
Edward Spicer.
55. Mearns, "Ancient Dwellings,"
746.
56. Ibid., 763.
57. Mindeleff was the first
professional archeologist to do work in the Verde Valley, but it appears
that both Frank Cushing of the Smithsonian and Adolph Bandelier were in
the area in the early 1880s. Reference to their presence in the area can
be found in Weekly Arizona Miner. 29 July 1881, 3, and Arizona
Silver Belt, 19 May 1883, 3.
58. Cosmos Mindeleff, "Aboriginal
Remains in the Verde Valley, Arizona," in 13th Annual Report of the
Bureau of American Ethnology (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing
Office, 1896), 179261.
59. Jesse Walter Fewkes,
"Archeological Expedition to Arizona in 1895," in 17th Annual Report
of the Bureau of American Ethnology (Washington, D.C.: Government
Printing Office, 1898). 51946. His later research appeared in
"Antiquities of the Upper Verde River and Walnut Canyon Valleys,
Arizona," in 28th Annual Report of the Bureau of American
Ethnology (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1912).
60. Robert H. Lister and Florence C.
Lister, Those Who Came Before (Tucson: Southwest Parks and
Monuments Association, 1983), 14344.
|