MEANINGFUL INTERPRETATION
How To Connect Hearts And Minds To Places, Objects, And Other Resources
Eastern National Logo

"...TO REVEAL THE UNIVERSAL IS THE HIGHEST KIND OF GREATNESS IN ANY REALM."
—Harry Emerson Fosdick


MORE RELEVANT TO MORE PEOPLE

Journal Questions:


How do you connect with total strangers? What are your tricks?




Are you good at it? Why or why not?



YOUR COLLEAGUES SAID...
How do you connect with total strangers? Are you good at it?

HOW DO YOU CONNECT WITH TOTAL STRANGERS?

"I usually ask them where they are from, what they do for a living, and perhaps what their leisure-time pursuits may be. I try to relate my experiences to theirs if I can."

"I try to read people's actions."

"Eye contact. Smile. Questions. Open gestures."

"I make mention of the sports team or town displayed on their clothes. It's an immediate connection — the wall between us is immediately down."

"I use empathy, I try to put myself in their shoes."

ARE YOU GOOD AT IT?

"No. I always feel as if I'm prying."

"Somewhat, I'm sometimes too focused on the resource to be completely at ease with the visitor."

"I don't feel very confident at it so I brace myself, but I'm a fairly good listener and enjoy learning about the visitor and conversing with them about the resource."

"Yes, because I sincerely try to make the interpretive presentation something they will remember and enjoy."

"Yes. I'm not as self-centered as when I was younger."

"Yes. I can read people very well. Just instinct I guess."

"Yes, because I enjoy what I do and believe in it."


ASSIGNMENT

See Part 7 of the video, More Relevant to More People, or read Section Nine of the text, An Interpretive Dialogue.

Some intangible meanings are powerful: they speak to, capture the attention of, and are more relevant to more people than other intangible meanings. The most compelling and broadly relevant meanings are universal concepts, ideas and notions that almost everyone can relate to, but do not mean the same to any two people. Examples of universal concepts include: joy, death, family, suffering, love, and birth.

There are many more processes, systems, relationships, and values that are also universal concepts. Audiences presented with tangible/intangible links that include universal concepts are offered the opportunity to relate their own perspectives to the resource as well explore the way others relate.

EXERCISE
clipboard

Brainstorm a list of concepts you believe are universal. Your list will be different than your colleagues' lists. A definitive list of universal concepts is probably not possible or even helpful to the profession. It's important though to check the validity of your ideas.

To be universal, any concept on your list must mean something significant to almost anyone. Test your concepts by considering a variety of audiences. Would this concept mean anything significant to them?

Journal Questions:


How do you know what is relevant to your audience?



YOUR COLLEAGUES SAID...
How do you know what is relevant to your audience?

"I often ask what my audience hopes to get out of guided tours before we start."

"Partly from listening to the questions of past visitors. Partly because I ask people. Partly because I evaluate and compare the feedback that I get on a variety of products."

"I know what's relevant to my audience by observing different audiences interacting with the many different aspects of the resource."

"I try to pick up on their current stresses — kids, weather, time, etc."

"It's not always easy, 26 million visitors and every one has different ideas of what is relevant. I ask. I guess. I point out many meanings."

"I assume the material related to the resource is in some way relevant to them. I also ask them what they think."

"I think we can presume there are certain things in life that are common to the human experience."

"That's a hard question. I don't know that you can always know what is relevant to your audience."

"You don't. You can get a sense of your audience by talking to them but relevance will be different for each person."

"After 30 years I don't know what is relevant to my wife. The question is monumentally egotistical and there are no real answers. One tries to find interest through clues like age, language, geography, demographics, subject-matter interest, repeat visits. Be diverse, don't generalize too much, invite participation, clarify complicated information, and interpret universals."


"UNIVERSAL: ANY GENERAL OR WIDELY HELD PRINCIPAL, CONCEPT, OR NOTION."
The American Heritage Dictionary Of The English Language
EXERCISE
clipboard

Look at the list of meanings you linked to a tangible resource on Page 110. Are any of these meanings universal concepts? Can you add more?

Human or Natural?

Universal concepts articulate human values and ideas and they are just as effective for natural history. While it can be persuasively argued the natural world has an inherent value independent of people, getting people to care enough to be stewards depends on how relevant the natural world is to them. Successful writers, speakers, and interpreters have been linking plants, animals, and features to intangible meanings since humans began to think about nature. Universal concepts like beauty, time, power, complexity, survival, sex, and change are at the very center of good natural history interpretation.

Consider the universal concept of survival. Does survival mean the same thing to the wolf as it does to the human? Does survival mean the same thing to a human in the present as it meant to a human in the 19th, 17th, or 14th centuries?

Even though survival represents a variety of meanings, it still has significance to almost all people and all resources. Because they are relevant, the stories and information that illustrate universal concepts like survival provoke new understanding and feelings. They help audiences explore differences.

EXERCISE
clipboard

Think about your lists of universal concepts. How does each universal apply differently to the natural and the human world?


"ALL OVER THE WORLD AND AT DIFFERENT TIMES OF HUMAN HISTORY, THESE ARCHETYPES, OR ELEMENTARY IDEAS, HAVE APPEARED IN DIFFERENT COSTUMES. THE DIFFERENCES IN THE COSTUMES ARE THE RESULTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND HISTORICAL CONDITIONS."
—Joseph Campbell

Universal Concepts and Relevance

One of Freeman Tilden's principles states, "Any interpretation that does not somehow relate what is being displayed or described to something within the personality or experience of the visitor will be sterile."*

*FREEMAN TILDEN, INTERPRETING OUR HERITAGE

It's easy to confuse little-r relevance with Big-R Relevance. Little-r relevance might catch the attention of the audience, but does not connect with the depth and significance of Big-R Relevance. For example, asking visitors where they are from is a common and valuable communication technique used by many interpreters. The answers provide information about a specific audience. However, the exchange will likely establish little-r relevance because it's hard to connect a random hometown to something powerfully meaningful in the resource.

Universal concepts provide Big-R Relevance. Universal concepts touch the personality and experience of the visitor. Freeman Tilden understood interpretation's power comes from Big-R Relevance — the ideas, values, relationships, challenges, and circumstances that define the human condition.

It's smart to ask visitors where they are from, but a good interpreter also links the tangible resource to universal concepts.


"IN EVERY MAN'S HEART THERE IS A SECRET NERVE THAT ANSWERS TO THE VIBRATIONS OF BEAUTY."
—Christopher Morley
EXERCISE
clipboard

Analyze your most successful interpretive products — the programs that most visitors respond to most of the time. Do they use universal concepts? What are they?

Analyze your less successful interpretive products. Do they use universal concepts? What universal concepts can you apply to those products to make them more successful?



<<< Previous <<< Contents>>> Next >>>


meaningful_interpretation/mi6i.htm
Last Updated: 29-May-2008

Meaningful Interpretation
©2003, Eastern National
All rights reserved by Eastern National. Material from this electronic edition published by Eastern National may not be reproduced in any manner without the written consent of Eastern National.