Lesson Plan 4: Remember the Ladies
Table of Contents
Title
Overview
Museum Collections, Similar Items and Other Materials Used
National Educational Standards
Student Learning Objectives
Background and Historical Context
Vocabulary
Teacher Tips
Lesson Implementation Procedures
Evaluation/Assessment for Measurable Results
Extension and Enrichment Activities
Resources
Site Visit
Charts, Figures and Other Teacher Materials



A. The Winter at Valley Forge
  • Developers: Verena Calas, National Park Service Museum Educator, Washington D.C
  • Grade Level: 6-8 grades
  • Number of Sessions in the Lesson Unit Plan: 5
    [Back to top]
B. Overview of this Collection-Based Lesson Unit Plan
  • Park Name: This lesson unit plan draws on the extraordinary Valley Forge National Historic Park museum collections featured in the virtual museum exhibit at www.nps.gov/museum.
  • Description: Students will explore the challenges experienced by the Continental Army and its leadership, including General Washington, during their encampment at Valley Forge during the winter of 1777-1778 through object-based learning, hands-on activities, and active research. Students will work with and analyze primary source materials; including original Washington correspondence and other related documentation. Students will have the opportunity to make connections between the Revolutionary War period and the present by examining the similarities and differences between the original training manual of General Von Steuben and modern military manuals. Students will also practice analytical research, close reading, and debate skills through the examination of symbolism in colonial currency, the analysis of 18th century portraiture, and the discussion of women's role in the military.    
  • Essential Question: During the American Revolution, General Washington and the fledgling Continental Army encountered many obstacles. However, from the Valley Forge encampment they emerge an organized and trained fighting force. Therefore, what obstacles did soldiers encounter while at Valley Forge? And, what factors contributed its emergence as a trained professional fighting force?

    The following lesson plans are organized individually but make up a cohesive unit plan for "The Winter at Valley Forge". Teachers can choose to teach all five lessons as a unit, or each individually.

    Lesson Overviews
    • Lesson Plan 1: Daily Life at the Valley Forge Camp: This lesson introduces students to the challenges experienced by every day soldiers and their commanding officers during the winter at Valley Forge and explores how they dealt with these challenges not only physically, but mentally, as well.
      • Activity 1: Washington's Frustration
      • Activity 2: Rucksack Rummage
    • Lesson Plan 2: In Their Own Words: This lesson introduces students to the primary source documentation and analysis through the correspondence of men living in the Valley Forge encampment. Students will get another look into the challenges the camp presents as well as the emotional toll war can on the soldiers fighting it.
      • Activity 1: The Voices of Valley Forge
      • Activity 2: A Postcard Home
    • Lesson Plan 3: Von Steuben Makes an Army: This lesson explores the military training and tactics introduced by General Von Steuben at Valley Forge. Students will explore the importance of military manuals as modes of sharing information amongst large organized groups.
      • Activity 1: Who is Von Steuben?
      • Activity 2: Document Transcription and Translation
      • Activity 3: Creating a Manual
    • Lesson Plan 4: Remember the Ladies: This lesson explores the various rolls of women at the Valley Forge encampment. Students will compare the experiences of Valley Forge women to the changing rolls of American women in the military throughout history and partake in a class debate.
      • Activity 1: Who are the women of Valley Forge?
      • Activity 2: The Different Women of War, Independent Research
      • Activity 3: Class Debate
    • Lesson Plan 5: The Economy of War: This lesson explores the different kinds of currency and symbolism used not only in the Valley Forge Camp, but in the Thirteen Colonies at large. Students will also engage in the mathematical exchange of money.
      • Activity 1: Symbolism in Colonial, Continental, and Modern Currency
      • Activity 2: Redesign of the Dollar Bill
      • Activity 3: Converting Currency

      [Back to top]
C. Museum Collections, Similar Items and other Materials Used in this Lesson Unit Plan
This lesson introduces students to the challenges experienced by every day soldiers and their commanding officers during the winter at Valley Forge and explores how they dealt with these challenges not only physically, but mentally, as well.
MUSEUM OBJECT [photos of objects in the Parks museum collections] SIMILAR OBJECTS [local items similar to museum objects] & OTHER MATERIALS Length of time

Activity 1: Who are the women of Valley Forge?

Similar Items [similar to objects in the Park museum collection]:

Activity 1: Who are the women of Valley Forge?


 

20 minutes

Activity 2: The Different Women of War, Independent Research

Women's Shoes Hatchel

Women's Shoes

Hatchel
Tissue and Dressing Forceps Thimble

Tissue and Dressing Forceps

Thimble
Buzzer Pressing Iron

Buzzer

Pressing Iron

General and Mrs. Washington's Bedroom Tea kettle

General and Mrs. Washington's Bedroom

Tea kettle

Similar Items [similar to objects in the Park museum collection]:


 

60
minutes

Activity 3: Class Debate

Similar Items [similar to objects in the Park museum collection]:

Activity 3: Class Debate

  • Stopwatch/timer
  • Note cards (if needed)
  • Journals/Notebooks
  • Class Debate Guide (provided in supplementary documents)

 

50 minutes

[Back to top]
D. National Educational Standards

NSS-USH 5-12 Era 3 – Revolution and the New Nation (1754-1820's)
Standard 1
Understands the causes of the American Revolution, the ideas and interests involved in forging the revolutionary movement, and the reasons for the American victory.

Standard 2
Understands the impact of the American Revolution on politics, economy, and society

Common Core Standards
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.6-8.9
Analyze the relationship between a primary and secondary source on the same topic.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.1 Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources, attending to such features as the date and origin of the information.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.2
Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source; provide an accurate summary of how key events or ideas develop over the course of the text.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.9 Compare and contrast treatments of the same topic in several primary and secondary sources

[Back to top]
E. Student Learning Objectives

Objectives
  • SWBAT describe the roles of different women within the Valley Forge encampment and the difficulties they faced.
  • SWBAT make connections between the women at Valley Forge and the changing role of women in the U.S. war effort and armed services.

Skills
  • SWBAT research original content in preparation for a debate.
  • SWBAT create an argument with supporting evidence around a debate topic.

[Back to top]
F. Background and Historical Context
The Winter at Valley Forge: Background Information PowerPoint (slide 16)
Valley Forge National Historic Park Website: The Women Present at Valley Forge

[Back to top]

G. Vocabulary

Affirmative: agreeing with a statement or request. Negative: a word or statement that expresses disagreement.
Opening Statements: a paragraph outlining the main points of reasoning for your argument to be presented at the beginning of the debate.
Closing Statements: a paragraph summarizing the main points of reasoning for your argument to be presented at the end of the debate.
Individual Arguments: each person on the team must speak at least ONCE and present original evidence to support your team’s argument.

H. Teacher Tips
  • Split lesson into multiple days for different phases of research of and debate.
  • Create more debate topics surrounding women and the military for smaller group debates depending on class size.


[Back to top]
I. Lesson Implementation Procedures
Lesson 4, Activity 1: Who are the women of Valley Forge?
Time Instructional Sequence Teacher Narration Exemplary Responses & Follow Up Questions
10 mins Post Warm Up question and portrait of Martha Washington on the board for students to answer.
  • American women have been a crucial part of every conflict in our history. They have served as ambulance drives, pilots, administrators, nurses, and mechanics. However, it is only in 1991 that women are officially allowed to enter combat zones and fight alongside their male counterparts. If you are a woman in 1777, what are ways in which you could help the Revolutionary War effort? (Think about the different circumstances surrounding women at the time including marital status, race, and socioeconomic class). And, would women have been present at the Valley Forge encampment?

Allow students to share with a partner
  • Women could have made supplies for the war effort.
  • Women could have cooked for troops or been nurses, they wouldn’t have fought like men at the time.
  • No, women would not have been at Valley Forge because no one but soldiers can be within a military encampment.
  • Yes, women would have been at Valley Forge because wounded and sick soldiers would have needed care and women would have been the primary group to do this.
10 mins Project photographs of both camp objects and those belonging to Martha Washington to give students inspiration.

Allow students to share their responses and foster a discussion about to whom the objects would have belonged and their jobs within the Valley Forge camp.
Lesson 4, Activity 2: The Different Women of War, Independent Research
Time Instructional Sequence Teacher Narration Exemplary Responses & Follow Up Questions
10 mins Split students into groups of three 3 to 4 students.

Give each group and different grouping of objects that includes:
  • A picture of a living space
  • 2 to 3 similar objects from the list


Example Grouping:
  • Image – Huts in the Snow (VAFO 11.21)
  • Kitchen Spatula
  • Tea Kettle
  • Child’s rattle
10 mins Tell groups that each set of objects is indicative of a woman and her role at the Valley Forge encampment. Using the objects as their evidence, ask them to describe three to four aspects of the woman depicted by the objects and cite their evidence.

Allow students to share their responses with the entire class.

Discuss the similarities and differences between the women depicted through the objects.


We know this woman most likely wasn’t wealthy because she lived in a log cabin during the encampment and because she worked with the troops.

We know this woman probably cooked for the troops because the kitchen spatula and tea kettle are both kitchen items.

We know this woman probably lived alongside the male troops or with her husband who was a soldier by evidence of the log cabin.

We know this woman most likely had children with her because of the presence of the baby rattle.
40 mins Give instructions for the upcoming debate in Activity 3 and reveal the topic:
  • Should women be allowed to fight in combat zones?

Split class into either the “Affirmative” or “Negative” side of the argument.

Hand out Class Debate Guide (provided in supplementary materials)

Groups should prepare opening statements outlining their argument to be presented at the very beginning of the debate and closing statements to summarize their arguments presented at the very end of the debate.

Using the NPS Valley Forge website and other sources, allow students to do research on any Valley Forge women of their choosing and other women from a modern conflicts provided in the supplementary documents.

Allow students to take notes on their findings



Lesson 4, Activity 3: Class Debate
Time Instructional Sequence Teacher Narration Exemplary Responses & Follow Up Questions
10 mins Using their research on women in the U.S. war movement, students should prepare for a debate on the issue – Should women be allowed to serve in active duty of the armed services?

Outline rules of the debate according to your classroom standards.

Recommended standards:
  • Affirmative will start
  • Each student will be given the chance to speak for their team in a given order.
  • Individual speaking time will not exceed two minutes per student.

Students should be prepared to speak when called upon otherwise the opportunity will be passed to the next person.


40 mins Using a timer or stopwatch, begin debate.

J. Evaluation/Assessment for Measurable Results
  • Adequate performance in class debate in accordance with standards laid out by teacher.
K. Extension and Enrichment Activities
[Back to top]
L. Resources
Other Materials Listed in Sections C
M. Site Visit

  • Visit the Valley Forge National Historic Park Virtual Exhibition
  • Visit the Valley Forge National Historic Park Website
N. Charts, Figures and other Teacher MaterialsSupplementary Materials Listed in Sections C


Lesson Title Page(s)
Lesson 4, Activity 2&3 Class Debate Guide 22-23