Long Range Interpretive Plan The National Park Service (NPS) has adopted a unified planning approach for interpretation and education.This approach combines planning for interpretive media, personal interpretive services, and education programs. The Long-Range Interpretive Plan is the basic planning document for interpretation and was formally adopted as part of NPS guidelines in 1995. Responsibility for creating the LRIP lies with each park’s superintendent.
The planning process helps parks make practical, goal-driven choices. The LRIP defines the overall vision and long-term (five to seven years) interpretive goals of the park and articulates realistic strategies and actions that work toward achieving those goals. While it considers past interpretive approaches, the LRIP is primarily a forward-looking document that concentrates on actions needed to create or sustain a vigorous and effective interpretive program for the future. The long-range interpretive planning process features two phases. First, the foundation phase articulates significance, themes, and target audiences. It also includes a review of existing conditions. The second phase of the LRIP process recom- mends interpretive services, media, and partnerships for the site, looking ahead to the next five to seven years.An Implementation Plan divides the recommendations into achievable steps. National parks are created to preserve our past, to tell us about ourselves, and to inspire us. Parks may offer us a picture of what has gone by, but this image is never static. The passage of time helps shapeour opinions about events and ideas. Whereas the initial purpose of a park may have been to tell a historic story, time may come to show that the park has new and even more important roles in the life of a community. This dynamic process compels those of us charged with preserving and interpreting these important slices of the American story to give serious attention to their changing role and how we tell these stories.
The staff at Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site is inspired by and dedicated to the concept of the park as a transformative force, not just for individuals, but for the surrounding community. Our neighbors have shared that they often want more from the site than they are presently receiving.They want to understand the role of the park in their lives, how it might help children receive a better education and how it helps them connect with their natural surroundings, and in ways that go beyond simply learning the history of the civil rights movement. As a result, the park has made a significant commitment to creating a Long-Range Interpretive Plan (LRIP) that builds on and is informed by the wishes and needs of the community. The LRIP process therefore has involved a great deal of civic engagement and dialogue withthe community. This dialogue will continue to have a role in managing and planning in the park in the future. This plan is a reflection of our commitment to civic engagement and an invitation to continued and active community dialogue in helping to shape the park’s future. This section presents a brief narrative describing the park’s enabling legislation.A copy of the park’s enabling leg- islation is included as Appendix A.Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site (NHS) was established in Topeka, Kansas, on October 26, 1992, by Public Law 102-525. The site, which includes the historic Monroe School and adjacent grounds, commemorates the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that ended segregation in public schools throughout the nation. The legislation permits the park to develop cooperative agreements with private and public agencies, organizations, and institutions within or beyond Topeka to further the park’s mission. These partnerships are meant to ensure that the full story of the events that preceded andfollowed the historic U.S. Supreme Court decision will be told.
Park purpose statements describe why a site was set aside and what specific purposes exist for it.The purposes of Brown v. Board of Education NHS, as quoted from the park’s enabling legislation, are to:
The mission statement describes what the park does.Brown v. Board of Education NHS interprets, for the benefit andinspiration of present and future generations, the people, places, and events that contributed to the landmark United States Supreme Court decision that outlawed segregation in public education.Furthermore, the site interprets the integral role of the Brown v. Board of Education case in the civil rights movement, preserves the former Monroe School and cultural land- scape, and assists in the interpreta- tion of related local, national, and international resources that further the understanding of the civil rights movement.
The vision statement tells why the park does what it does. It describes the mission goals.The vision of Brown v. Board of Education NHS is to:
Park significance statements describe what is distinctive about the combined resources of the park. The statements can reflect natural, cultural, scientific, recreational, and inspirational values, as well as other aspects. These statements summarize the importance of the park to the nation’s natural and cultural heritage.
Brown v. Board of Education NHS is significant to the nation because: The Case of the Century.Brown v. Board of Education declared the doctrine of “separate but equal” in the nation’s educational system unconstitutional by overturning the precedent set in 1896 by Plessy v. Ferguson.A Right Guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.The Brown v. Board of Education decision affirmed the Constitutional right of all U. S. citizens to equal protection under the law as guaranteed by the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.Legacy and Impact.The Brown v. Board of Education decision represents a crucial turning point in the American civil rights movement by establishing a legal precedent for dismantling other forms of legalized segregation in the country, which led to new opportunities for African Americans and other minorities to achieve equality not only in education, but in housing, employment, and many other realms.Kansas and the struggle for equality and freedom.From the struggle over the expansion of slavery during the “Bleeding Kansas” era before the Civil War, to the U.S. Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education, to conflicts over the civil rights of other groups such as gays and lesbians, the people of the state of Kansas have been witness to the foundation of fundamental paradigm shifts in the national struggle for equality. Primary interpretive themes embody the most important ideas or concepts communicated to the public about a park. They convey the significance of the resource, and highlight the links between tangible elements, intangible meanings, and universal concepts that are inherent in the park’s resources.The themes connect resources to larger processes, systems, ideas, and values, and emphasize the relevance of park stories. They define the core content of the educational messages the park offers, and serve as the building blocks upon which interpretive services and educational programs are based.Subthemes identify the stories – potentially infinite in number — that can be told as part of each theme.
Primary interpretive themes, including some subthemes/stories, for Brown v. Board of Education NHS are: 1. The Brown v. Board of Education decision by the U.S. Supreme Court was the culmination of a century of personal struggles and legal battles in the fight to achieve racial equality in the United States and continues to influence the everyday lives of Americans today. The focus of this theme is on the “Road to Brown” and the case itself, and it is intended to convey the significance of the “case of the century” as the result of the efforts of many people.STORIES / SUBTHEMES INCLUDE:
2. The Brown v. Board of Education decision provided the legal, social, moral, and philosophical underpinning for the major civil rights actions later taken by citizens and the executive, judicial, and legislative branches of government, establishing a landmark precedent that continues to inform debate over the meaning of equality. The focus is on the subsequent impact of the case, and the theme is intended to convey its legacy.STORIES / SUBTHEMES INCLUDE:
3. The Monroe Elementary School reflects the excellence of all-black schools in an educational system in Topeka that implemented racial segregation in elementary schools, representing the conflicted attitudes and policies toward African Americans that have characterized Kansas from its bloody entry into the Union as a free state to its adoption of permissible segregation laws. The Brown v. Board of Education decision grew out of Kansas, a state that was deeply involved in the national struggle for freedom and equality from the 1850s to the 1950s. The focus of the theme is on the unique history and culture of Kansas, and it is intended to convey that significance.
STORIES / SUBTHEMES INCLUDE:
|
Interpretive Service |
Existing or New? |
Time Frame: Short-term (within 1 yr) Mid-term (2-3 yrs) Long-term (4-7 yrs) |
Priority within time frame (High Medium Low) |
Theme(s) Addressed |
Audiences Served |
Funding |
Status |
Existing or Potential Partner(s) |
ONSITE PERSONAL SERVICES |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dialogic tours |
New |
Mid-term |
High |
All |
Onsite ed, gen pub |
ONPS |
Explore |
Museum of the New South |
Scheduled formal interpretive programs |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
All |
ONPS |
Begin planning |
|
NPS-led Ranger tours, Ritchie house |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
3,4,5 |
School groups, spec tours |
ONPS |
Explore |
Shawnee Co. Historical Scty. |
Living History |
New |
Long-term |
Medium |
All |
Onsite ed, general pub |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
ONSITE EDUCATION |
||||||||
Dialogic Tours |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Students and teachers |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Trainers |
Teacher Work Groups |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Teachers |
ONPS |
Planned |
Local teachers |
Summer Camp activities for youth |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Local under- served |
NPF and ONPS |
Ongoing |
FFNHA and NPF |
Williams Afterschool |
Existing |
Short |
High |
All |
Local children |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Williams ES |
Improve educational group reservation system |
Existing |
Short |
High |
N/A |
All student groups |
ONPS |
Planned |
|
Homeschool |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Children and parents |
ONPS |
Exploring |
|
Teacher Workshops |
Existing |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Teachers |
ONPS |
Planned |
Schools |
Bus grants |
Existing |
Long-term |
High |
N/A |
Schools |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Schools |
Kite Day |
Existing |
Long-term |
High |
N/A |
Williams ES |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Williams ES |
After-school homework |
New |
Long-term |
Low |
5 |
Local children |
ONPS |
Exploring |
PTA and schools |
OFFSITE EDUCATION |
||||||||
Topeka-specific curriculum |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Education 4-12 grades |
ONPS |
Begin planning |
Teachers in area |
National History Day |
Existing/ new |
Short |
High |
All |
Education 6-12 grades |
ONPS |
Begin planning |
Students in grades 6 to 12 |
Distance learning broadcasts |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
High |
All |
Education 4-12 grades |
ONPS |
Begin planning |
HOME, GRCA, Great Plains Network, We the People |
NPS park rangers in schools |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
High |
All |
All students |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Area teachers |
Summer youth days |
New |
Mid-term |
High |
3,5 |
Topeka kids |
ONPS |
Begin imple- menta- tion |
FFNHA Boys and Girls Club |
Teacher/Ranger teacher |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Teachers, students 4-12 grades |
ONPS |
Explore |
NPS T-R-T program |
Living history |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
1,3,5 |
School groups, special groups |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
|
Mock trial |
New |
Long-term |
Medium |
1,4,5 |
School groups grades 7-12 |
O NPS |
Explore |
Area teachers, Mr. Charles Scott, Jr. |
Student statewide art contest |
New |
Long-term |
Low |
3,5 |
Education grades 4-12 |
ONPS |
Explore |
KS Dept. of Ed |
OUTREACH (non-educational) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
KS Book Festival |
New |
Short-term |
High |
3,5 |
People who can read in Kansas |
ONPS |
Began planning |
WNPA, First Lady, Library |
Topeka and Shawnee Country Public Library Outreach |
Existing/ new |
Short-term |
High |
All |
Local |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
TSCPL |
Historic Ritchie House, Shawnee County Historical Society |
Existing/ new |
Short-term |
High |
3 |
Historical |
ONPS |
Exploring |
SCHS |
Constitution Hall in Topeka |
Existing/ new |
Short-term |
High |
3 |
Local historical, downtown pedestrians |
ONPS |
Began planning |
Friends of Constitution Hall |
Diversity Training Outreach |
New |
Mid-term |
High |
All |
Local area – esp. LE |
ONPS |
Exploring |
Area law enforcement |
Host regularly scheduled focus groups |
New |
Mid-term |
High |
All |
Local |
ONPS |
Exploring |
|
Work with 5 communities for web and virtual tours |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
4 |
Ed groups and 5 communities |
ONPS |
Exploring |
Moton Briggs Delaine |
Increase interpretation of other BvB sites |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
4 |
Ed groups and 5 communities |
ONPS |
Exploring |
Moton Briggs Delaine |
Lunch time “Brown Bag It” series |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Local |
ONPS |
Ongoing/ exploring |
|
Community outreach with civic groups |
Existing |
Mid-term |
Medium |
5 |
Local |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Many |
Bus tours |
New |
Long |
Medium |
3,5 |
Local |
ONPS |
Exploring |
|
BRVB parade float |
New |
Long |
Low |
TBD |
Local |
ONPS |
Exploring |
|
ONSITE EXHIBITS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Concept Plan |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
All |
ONPS |
Under contract |
|
Implement concept plan |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
All |
Staff time |
Will begin after Concept Plan |
|
Doll installed in exhibit |
New |
Short |
High |
1,2,4,5 |
On-site visitors |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
|
Purpose of 2nd floor |
New |
Short |
Med/High |
NA |
Community/Ed |
ONPS |
Not devel- oped |
TSCPL |
Visitor ID |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
On-site visitors |
ONPS |
Not devel- oped |
5 communities |
Interp Objects/Hands On Items |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
On-site visitors, children |
ONPS |
Not devel- oped |
Teachers, groups |
EXHIBITS AND SPECIAL EVENTS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Black Troops Traveling Exhibit/Living History Event |
New |
Short |
High |
3 |
Diverse, children, students |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
FOSC, KHS |
Black Expo Labor Day |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Local and diverse |
ONPS |
Planned |
Local black group |
National History Day |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Students |
ONPS |
Explored |
Schools and history groups |
Dream Rocket |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Students/ Adults |
ONPS |
Planned |
Dream Rocket Project coordinator |
Dia de los Muertos (“Day of the Dead”) |
New |
Short |
High |
3,5 |
Mexican- Americans |
ONPS |
Planned |
Mexican- American community |
Naturalization ceremonies |
Existing |
Short |
High |
5 |
Diverse |
NA |
Planned |
District Court |
Living History Walks: Ritchie House to BRVB |
Existing |
Short |
High |
3 |
Students and spec events audience |
ONPS |
Planned |
SCHS, Lecompton Players |
Artist In Residence |
New |
Short |
Medium |
All |
Local artists |
ONPS |
Planned |
Local art groups |
Lecture Series |
Existing |
Short |
Low |
All |
Local and academic, students |
ONPS |
Explore |
Schools |
UGRR Special event |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
1,5,3 |
|
|
|
|
Signature Annual Event |
New |
Long |
Medium |
All |
Students, Local community |
ONPS |
Explore |
Many |
Special event with the 5 Communities |
New |
Long |
Low |
4 |
TBD |
ONPS |
Explored |
5 Communities |
MEDIA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Waysides |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Onsite/ community |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
SCHS, Constitution Hall |
“Brown to Brown” Brochure of Topeka sites |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Topeka Community, travelers |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
SCHS Constitution Hall |
Cell phone tour |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Topeka community, travelers |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
SCHA, Constitution Hall |
BRVB Traveling Exhibit |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Offsite |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
BRVB Newsletter |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Onsite, com- munity, NPS community |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
Podcasts for website |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Web com- munity |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
|
Web Ranger |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Web students |
ONPS |
Explore |
All other NPS Civil Rights sites |
Multi-lingual media |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Non-English- speaking visitors |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
Pub relations/market |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
New visitors |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
Visit Topeka (CVB) |
Media database |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Staff, NPS, NHD |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
Social Media |
Existing/ New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Web com- munity |
ONPS |
Ongoing |
|
E-tour |
New |
Long |
Medium |
All |
Web com- munity |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
SB for all 5 communities |
New |
Long |
Medium |
All |
Outreach and onsite |
ONPS |
Explore |
5 communities |
After visit postcard project |
New |
Long |
Low |
All |
Onsite |
ONPS |
Explore |
|
ACCESSIBILITY |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Light Plan |
New |
Short |
High |
NA |
All onsite visitors, ADA community |
ONPS |
In progress |
ADA com- munity, HFC |
Sound Plan |
New |
Short |
High |
NA |
All onsite visitors, ADA community |
ONPS |
In progress |
ADA com- munity, HFC |
Large print brochures |
New |
Short |
Medium |
NA |
Vision impaired visitors |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
ADA com- munity |
Tactile school exterior and floor plan |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
NA |
All onsite visitors, vision impaired |
ONPS |
In progress |
ADA com- munity |
Assistive Listening & audio descriptive |
New |
Mid-term |
Medium |
NA |
Hearing impaired |
ONPS |
Under develop- ment |
ADA com- munity |
INTERPRETIVE INFRASTRUCTURE |
||||||||
Oral History Collection |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
Elderly staff and visitors |
ONPS |
Began planning |
|
Use of NPS bus from TAPR |
New |
Short |
High |
All |
School, local, historical |
ONPS |
Began planning |
|
Professional development of interpre- tive staff |
Existing/ new |
Short |
High |
All |
Staff |
ONPS |
Began planning |
|
Update BRVB park library |
Existing/ new |
Mid-term |
Medium |
All |
Staff and public |
ONPS |
Began planning |
|
Database of primary source documents |
New |
Mid-term |
Low |
All |
Virtual visitors |
ONPS |
Exploring |
|
BROWN v. BOARD OF EDUCATION NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE
For Signing Statement of Act, see Statement for P.I. 102525 in U.S.C.C. & A. N. Legislative History Section.
An act ot provide for the establishment of the Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site in the State of Kansas, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of The United States of America in Congress assembled.
TITLE 1
BROWN V. BOARD OF EDUCATION NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE SEC. 101. DEFINITIONS
As used in this title-
- the term "Secretary" means the Secretary of the Interior
- The term "historic site" means the Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site as established in section 103
-
- FINDINGS.The Congress finds as follows:
- The Supreme Court, in 1954, ruled that the earlier 1896 Supreme Court decision in Plessy v. Ferguson that permitted segregation of races in elementary schools violated the fourteenth amendment to the United States Constitution, which guarantees all citizens equal protection of the law.
- In the 1954 proceedings, Oliver Brown and 12 other plaintiffs successfully challenged an 1879 Kansas Law that had been patterned after the law in question in Plessy v. Ferguson after the Topeka, Kansas, Board of Education refused to enroll Mr. Brown's daughter Linda.
- Sumner Elementary, the allwhite school that refused to enroll Linda Brown, and Monroe Elementary, the segregated school she was forced to attend, have subsequently been designated National Historic Landmarks in recognition of their national significance.
- Sumner Elementary, an active school, is administered by the Topeka Board of Education; Monroe Elementary, closed in 1975 due to declining enrollment, is privately owned and stands vacant.
- PURPOSES.The purposes of this title are-
- preserve, protect, and interpret for the benefit and enjoyment of present and future generations, the places that contributed materially to the landmark United States Supreme Court decision that brought and end to segregation in public education;
- FINDINGS.The Congress finds as follows:
-
-
- interpret the integral role of the Brown v. Board of Education case in the civil rights movement; and
- assist in the preservation and interpretation of related resources within the city of Topeka that further the understanding of the civil rights movement.
-
SEC. 103. ESTABLISHMENT OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS IN EDUCATION: BROWN V. BOARD OF EDUCATION NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE
-
-
-
- IN GENERAL.There is hereby established as a unit of the National Park System the Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site in the State of Kansas.
- DESCRIPTION.The historic site shall consist of the Monroe Elementary School site in the city of Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas, as generally depicted on a map entitled "Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site," numbered Appendix A and dated June 1992. Such map shall be on file and available for public inspection in the appropriate offices in the National Park Service.
-
-
SEC. 104. PROPERTY ACQUISITION.
The Secretary is authorized to acquire by donation, exchange, or purchase with donated or appropriated funds the real property described in section 103(b). Any property owned by the States of Kansas or any political subdivision thereof may also acquire by the same methods personal property associated with, and appropriate for, the interpretation of the historic site: Provided, however, That the Secretary may not acquire such personal property without the consent of the owner.SEC. 105. ADMINSTRATION OF HISTORIC SITE.
- IN GENERALThe Secretary shall administer the historic site in accordance with this title and the laws generally applicable to units of the National Park System, including the Act of August 25, 1916 (39 Stat. 535), and the Act of August 21, 1935 (49 Stat. 666).
- COOPERATIVE AGREEMENTS.The Secretary is authorized to enter into cooperative agreements with private as well as public agencies, organizations, and institutions in furtherance of the purposes of this title.
- GENERAL MANAGEMENT PLAN.Within two complete fiscal years after funds are made available, the Secretary shall prepare and submit to the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs of the United States House of Representatives and the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources of the United States Senate a general management plan for the historic site.
SEC. 106. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.
There are authorized to be appropriated $1,250,000 to carry out the purposes of this title including land acquisition and initial development.Accessibility Assessment for Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site Key Findings & Recommendations
Assessment date: April 6, 2009 – April 8, 2009In April 2009, two staff members from the National Center on Accessibility (NCA) spent three days at the Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site, completing a physical and programmatic accessibility assessment. This report outlines the key findings and recommendations found during the assessment. The purpose of this report is to identify access deficiencies to NPS facilities and programs in order to prioritize and expedite the appropriate corrective actions and recommendations required under the federal disability legislative mandates.
Physical and Programmatic Accessibility
The Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 requires that buildings and facilities that are designed, constructed, or altered with Federal funds, or leased by a Federal agency, comply with Federal standards for physical accessibility.Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended states that people with disabilities cannot be denied the benefits of or be excluded from the participation in programs, services and activities. Section 508 requires that communications with individuals with disabilities are as effective as communications with others specifically as it relates to electronic and information technology.Referenced Documents Used for Site Assessments and RecommendationsThe following documents have been used based on the legislative mandates to which the National Park Service must adhere regarding accessibility for people with disabilities: Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 as amended (U.S. Access Board, 2004; General Services Administration, effective date May 8, 2006). Rehabilitation Act of 1973 as amended in 1978, Section 504 (program access), Section 501 (employment), Section 508 (electronic and information technology, which includes video and multimedia, web sites, computer kiosks, etc.) NPS Director’s Order #42: Accessibility for Visitors with Disabilities in National Park Service Programs and Service National Park Service Programmatic Accessibility Guidelines for Interpretive Media NPS Audio-Visual Accessibility Initiative for Visitors with Disabilities D24(2420) (October 20, 2006)In addition to legislative mandates, the NCA assessment team has made recommendations based on best practices in the field to create greater opportunities for participation and benefit among visitors with disabilities:Principles of Universal DesignSmithsonian Guidelines for Accessible Exhibition DesignWeb Accessibility in Mind. (n.d.). Seizure Disorders Introduction. Retrieved May 19, 2009, from WebAIM Web Site: http://www.webaim.org/articles/seizure/ EZ Access. (n.d.). Retrieved May 20, 2009, from http://trace.wisc.edu/handouts/ez-intro/ Reich, C. (2006). Universal Design of Computer Interactives for Museum Exhibits. Retrieved May 19, 2009, from Museum of Science Boston Web Site: http://www.mos.org/exhibitdevelopment/access/index.htmlThe following report is a compilation of the most significant deficiencies that were identified by the National Center on Accessibility (NCA).
Key Findings and Recommendations
The scope of this project called for NCA to work with the Brown v. Board of Education National Historic Site to identify all of the programmatic and physical deficiencies at the site. The following narrative report provides details of the NCA assessment team’s key findings and recommendations.
Reoccurring Barriers to Physical Accessibility
SeatingFound throughout the Brown v. Board building are square, padded seats to be used as seating for visitors. There are two versions of these seats. One version which is found in the auditorium has backrests but no arm rests. The second version is just a padded cube that does not provide either a backrest or an arm rest. These are found in all of the remaining galleries. Neither of the versions of the seats is fixed within any location.They were frequently moved around in each of the galleries, mostly resulting in them being scattered in the way of where people walk, and often times eliminating the necessary clear floor space required for maneuvering. They are also placed at the computer exhibits to be used as seats, but for a visitor using a wheelchair they would have to move them out of the way to gain access to the knee clearance at the exhibits. The seats require approximately 10 pounds of operating force to move them, which creates an obstacle to gaining knee clearance and possibly may not be feasible for some visitors. NCA recommends the park add a plastic cap or felt material to the existing metal fittings on the bottom of the chairs so that they can be more easily slid across the wood floors.There are many locations throughout Brown v Board where it would be appropriate to add fixed accessible seating as opposed to removing the cubes that are currently there.
These instances would be in all of the theatres and areas where the intention is for a visitor to sit and watch a video.DoorsMany of the doors located throughout Brown v. Board have an operating force that exceeds the maximum allowed 5 pounds for an interior door (ABAAS 404.2.9). The park shall ensure that all doors meet these requirements. At the time of the assessment, the following doors exceeded the maximum allowed force: the resource door (10lbs), the door to Expression and Reflections gallery (12lbs), the doors to the Legacy gallery (15lbs), the door to the Education and Justice gallery (15lbs), the women’s restroom (12lbs), both doors to the men’s restroom (16lbs), the doors to the auditorium (15lbs) and the door to the outside adjacent to the men’s restroom (23lbs).HardwareLocated throughout the four exhibit galleries, are a series of Discover Drawers. The drawers contain either photo panels or exhibit cases with period artifacts. The hardware on the drawers cannot be easily operated with the heel of the hand or a closed fist because the gap between the handle and drawer is not large enough. There are a total of eight handles that should be replaced throughout the site. Ensure that the requirements set forth in ABAAS for operable parts are met.
Reoccurring Barriers to Program Accessibility
PublicationsThe primary publications for Brown v. Board of Education NHS should be available in large print, Braille, audio and electronic formats. At the time of the assessment, the primary publications were not available in any alternative formats. NPS and local resources should be identified to produce secondary publications in alternative formats upon request. Secondary publications should include the statement, “This publication available in alternative format upon request (xx days in advance).”Include a statement in the Brown v. Board of Education NHS brochure explaining the availability of services for visitors with disabilities including information to request a sign language interpreter, audio describer, or real time captioning, along with information on the assistive listening systems, alternate formats, accessibility improvements to Brownv. Board of Education NHS and a contact number for more questions on accessibility. Also include this statement on the Brown v. Board of Education web site.Audio DescriptionA self-guided tour of the site is available. No audio description is provided for any exhibits throughout Brown v. Board of Education NHS. Visitors with visual or cognitive impairments currently do not have an equal opportunity to experience the site or exhibits. Due to the nature of the history of this site, the interpretation of the subject matter is done in a very graphic and visual nature, and not through a large collection ofphysical objects that can be made available for tactile examination. Therefore, access is provided through audio, computer interactives, and audio description, along with a limited amount of tactile objects. However, the park shall continue to explore other opportunities to enhance the experience at the park via hands on experience.Audio description is the describing of something visual to someone who is blind or who has low vision by a trained individual. The specialized training that audio describers receive enables them to look at objects, scenes and landscapes, people, and actions. Audio describers provide common language descriptions in a succinct and brief manner so that most people can understand what is being described. This can be done with a walking tour, a tour of a museum, films, videos, television, and other audio/visual products, and live performing art presentations.Audio description is professionally provided by individuals and organizations throughout the country and can be easily contracted in most states. Some national park units have audio description for museum tours, nature walks, and audio/visual productions. Audio description is required under both Section 504 and Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act and Director’s Order 42, which includes any use of multimedia production.A comprehensive audio tour system should be developed to provide visitors with a sequential experience as they visit each asset exhibit at the site. Audio guides shall be independently operated and hands-free or have a hands-free option so that visitors can explore available tactile exhibits. Transcripts of the audio tour shall be available in alternative formats. NCA recommends engaging a consultant to determine what the best approach would be for the park in creating the audio described tour (i.e. what will be included and how it will be incorporated). The park should seek guidance and recommendations from this consultant for equipment and its setup within the park. It may be possible (depending on the selected equipment and setup) to incorporate both the audio description and the portable assistive listening equipment. Equipment capable of multiple uses would minimize the burden on a visitor by not requiring multiple sets of devices and/or concern themselves with dropping off and picking up new equipment at different locations.The following are elements that should be considered when a consultant is contracted by the park to develop an audio described tour: An introduction to each room, inclusion of content from all audio visual programs, information received from the multiple interactive computer kiosks, the content in the flipbooks and on the graphic and text panels, and also the information in the discover drawers.Assistive Listening SystemsBrown v. Board of Education NHS offers guided tours with a Ranger or Interpreter (when staff is available). Special event programming also takes place on site. Assistive listening devices should be available for people with hearing loss to assist them in receiving the same information as other visitors on the tours or at special events.Assistive listening devices are also required for the film shown in the Auditorium. Portable assistive listening devices must be provided for visitors for guided tours or other presentations and special events. Display a sign at the information desk indicating
that the assistive listening system is available and publicize its availability through brochures, program announcements and the park website. All staff shall be trained in the use of the assistive technologies, the location of these auxiliary aids and park policy regarding interacting with people with disabilities. As stated above, the park should attempt to combine these devices with those that are being used for the audio described tour.Qualified sign language interpreters shall be available for scheduled tours and upon request for visitors who are deaf.Interactive Computer KiosksInteractive computer kiosks found throughout the galleries are all recessed into a counter, with a surrounding metal faceplate, and utilize touch screen technology. None of the screens have tactile controls nor do they have a built in assistive technology (such as screen readers) to help a person with low or no vision to navigate the exhibits independently. According to Section 508, if a product utilizes touch screens or touchoperated controls, redundant tactile input methods shall be provided. Tactile controls or keys outside of the screen that are discernable without the risk of interrupting the program functions of the computer are required. These tactile controls should also work in conjunction with a screen reader to allow for navigation of any menus and to allow for navigation of the content within the program on the computers. The Trace Center at the University of Wisconsin has developed a set of interface enhancements that can be applied to electronic products and devices so that they can be used by all people (the basic concept of Universal Design) including those visitors with disabilities (http://trace.wisc.edu/handouts/ez-intro). There is also a research article done by the Museum of Science, Boston that discusses the importance of Universal Design for Computer Interactives and gives an example of a tactile interface much like the one developed by the Trace Center (http://www.mos.org/exhibitdevelopment/access/index.html). A pdf of both resources is included on the final product cd the park is receiving.Section 508 also requires that the information provided via these interactive computer kiosk programs be audio described. Please see the section on audio description for a more detailed description of how to accomplish this.Tactile ExhibitsTactile interpretation is limited in the Brown v. Board of Education school and in the exhibit rooms. Ultimately, the goal is for all visitors to benefit and participate equally in the understanding of this historic time period. Throughout this narrative there will be a few recommendations for exhibits that could be made into tactile exhibits. The park shall continue to explore these options to enhance the experience of all visitors.Exhibit TextThe text on the exhibits and on the panels (both graphic and text) has reoccurring deficiencies. The graphic panels that reoccur throughout the four galleries are done inthe same format and layout and therefore all have the same deficiencies to note. The panels have a large photo that is typically 2/3rds the size of the panel. Under the photo is a small caption that describes the photo shown. Below that is a large serif title for the panel in black text. Below that is a red heading with a serif font that is too small. Below that is another text paragraph with a black serif font that is also too small. Exhibit text found throughout the galleries shall be a minimum of 36 point, have an accessible font (examples of accessible fonts are Arial, Century and Helvetica), and have a 90 percent contrast between the text and background. However, the size 36 point font is just a recommendation based on the approximate height of exhibit text during our visit. The park should refer to the Harpers Ferry Center guidelines on “Accessible Type by Probable Viewing Distance” for an exact type size for each individual exhibit.In addition, the park has avoided high use of italics, and NCA recommends avoiding the use of italics when redesigning the panel text. The park should also keep in mind that the red exhibit text does not create enough of a contrast between text and the background. A resource such as the Lighthouse for the Blind would be good to consult when looking at proper contrasting colors.An additional resource for exhibit text is the Smithsonian Guidelines for Accessible Exhibition Design.LightingLighting is a consistent problem throughout the Brown v Board galleries. The main source of light is a track lighting system that runs the full length of the gallery rooms that are angled to face the text and graphic panels along the walls and the information being provided on the angled counters. The angle of the lights on the panels cast a glare on the text making it difficult to read. In addition, the angle of the lights also cast a shadow on the text when you get up close to read it. The lighting is also inconsistent throughout the galleries – low in some places and then bright in others, which make it a difficult transition for people with low vision. According to the Smithsonian Guidelines for Accessible Exhibition Design sufficient light to read text is between 100 lux and 300 lux. The light shall also be at the same level as the light in the area immediately surrounding the text and must be uniform across the text. There are instances when the light is drastically dimmer just one photo panel over.The recommendation is to find a way to diffuse the light so that it is more even throughout the galleries. This may involve adding additional lights or replacing the existing track lighting.SoundThere are multiple instances throughout the exhibit galleries where sound bleed is a problem. Within the galleries, there are multiple sources of audio all playing at one time and most of them are on a continuous loop. To our knowledge, neither the walls nor ceiling are constructed of materials that would help to dampen and/or contain sound. As a result, the sound from one exhibit finds itself competing with the sound from the next
closest exhibit and so on. Each exhibit in the galleries has to be played at a volume level that is higher than its closest audio exhibit.Two concerns arise from competing sound sources and volume levels. The first concern is the potential for the decibel levels to be too high in some locations. One of these locations is the “Hall of Courage” where the sound is contained in a corridor. A second concern is that it is much more difficult for a person with hearing loss to decipher the information being given at each individual audio exhibit if there are multiple instances of audio.
Visitor Parking and Accessible Parking
The location of the visitor parking area is across the street from the Brown v. Board of Education building. The parking area is an unmarked lot that has a maximum capacity of 75 cars. There is good directional signage located on all cross streets and in the parking area indicating that the accessible parking is located behind the Brown v. Board of Education building. Where more than one parking facility is provided on a site, the number of accessible parking spaces provided on the site shall be calculated according to the number of spaces required for each parking facility. There are 17 spaces located in the back of the building to be used by employees for a total of 92 parking spaces. At the time of the assessment there was one designated van accessible parking space located behind the building. The existing van accessible parking space shall be relocated to the opposite end of parking area and the park shall add 3 accessible parking spaces adjacent to those. The park needs to relocate the van accessible space to ensure that the spaces are located on the closest accessible route to the open and unlocked entrance of the building. As a result of the front doors being too narrow, the only unlocked side door located near the bookstore becomes the accessible entrance. The park should implement a policy stating that this door remains unlocked during normal visitor hours. The only other entrance that is guaranteed to be open during business hours is the front entrance. To bring the access routes into compliance, the two ramps located on the North and South sides of the building need handrails. These handrails shall be added along both sides of the ramps meeting all requirements under ABAAS.
Entrance and Information Desk
The front entrance doors measure only 29 inches in width, which does not meet the required minimum width of 32 inches. If the park addresses parking as stated above and creates a policy wherein visitors are able to access Brown v. Board through the side entrance during normal business hours, the front doors will not need to be brought into compliance unless they are altered or replaced. The front doors are on a power assisted operating system and the park shall ensure that the closing speed of the door is a minimum of 5 seconds.NCA was asked to specifically assess the front access routes as the park was told they might be considered ramps. However, the running slope never exceeded 5 percent at any point for the full length of the routes and therefore is not considered a ramp. This negates the park from having to provide handrails at these access routes.Orientation for the visitor should begin as soon as they enter the building. Due to the historic significance and complexity of the subject matter presented at Brown v. Board of Education NHS, it is important that Audio Description begin prior to the visitor’s interaction with the interpretive exhibits and displays. In conjunction with the Audio Description, a 3-dimensional tactile model of the school building would provide the visitor with an understanding of the physical structure and a tactile map of the interior of the building would provide the visitor with an orientation of the site. An example of a tactile map frequently used is a thermoform map. Thermoform maps are raised line maps made from light-weight sheets of plastic created through a machine that uses a heating process that melts it into the raised line formations. Thermoform is the commercial name for this process used by the American Thermoform Corporation (www.atcbrleqp.com/). Providing a 3-dimensional model of the school and the tactile map of the interior of the building are not intended for the exclusive use of persons with visual impairments. They represent a universal approach to site orientation as they are usable by all visitors.Once through the front entrance doors, the visitor is in the entryway where they can stop in and gather information from a ranger at the information desk. The information counter is too high. The park shall provide a section of counter space that is 36 inches high maximum above the floor surface and that measures a minimum of 36 inches wide. This area should have signage that indicates accessibility accommodations available for visitors with disabilities, such as Audio Description and Assistive Listening Devices.
Auditorium
Across the north-south hallway and aligned directly with the entry hall is a doorway into the auditorium. Just inside this doorway (about five feet) is a baffle wall intended to block light spill into the auditorium and sound spill out of the auditorium. Mounted on the hall side of the baffle wall is the title of the show, “Race and the American Creed”. By turning either right or left we can go around this wall and enter the auditorium.The auditorium is home to the movie, “Race and the American Creed”. This is a multiscreen video program that is open-captioned with audio. It is bolstered by a series of graphic panels of iconic images and faces from the African American history as well as five iconic sculptures.The room is two-stories high with a balcony circling the space at the second story level. Mounted to the balcony railing are six rear-projection screens. Three televisions run along one side, facing three identical televisions that run along the other side. The televisions are mounted high, with their lower edges level with the floor of the balcony. The televisions are 6 feet by 8 feet and there is 8 foot of space between any two televisions. A seventh screen is located within the auditorium stage area. The six rearprojection televisions present two iterations of a single three-screen program. In this way, the program can be viewed wherever one stands in the auditorium. The seventh screen presents a synchronized moving collage of images complimentary to the threescreen program. All seven screens are open-captioned, but none of them are audio described. The auditorium also lacks an assistive listening system that would enable visitors with hearing loss to access the sound from the video. The way in which the
sound is amplified in the auditorium leads to a lot of sound bleed making it hard to discern the video. The park should consider providing sound cones above the seating in the auditorium to help direct the sound. These can be properly placed above the provided seating and would help to alleviate the sound bleed.The five iconic floor sculptures correspond to the five chapters of the video. These are “How Segregation Came to Be”, represented by a face-within-a-face; “Resistance”, represented by a group of artists mannequins pushing a boulder up a hill and, presumably, over a cliff. The boulder is emblazoned with words such as slavery and segregation; “War and National Service” represented by the logo for the Pittsburgh Courier’s Double V campaign (victory overseas and at home); “Education” represented by a stairway of books; “Civil Rights” represented by a scales of justice with white artists mannequins in one side and white and black mannequins climbing into the other side to try and level the scale. These iconic sculptures were not originally intended to be utilized as tactile exhibits, but after discussion with the park staff we have been notified that visitors are using them as such. The base of the five iconic sculptures measures 30 1/2 inches in height. From the top of the base to the top of the tactile features the height is an average of 65 inches. This means that the total height of the iconic sculptures measure approximately 8 feet. To be able to fully interpret the structures an individual is best served to be able to explore the figures with two hands. This means that a forward approach would be required and currently there is not knee clearance under the bases of the structures to afford an unobstructed reach. This makes the average reach range for an adult a maximum of approximately 44 inches in height. The average reach range for a child will range from 36 inches to 44 inches in height. If the park should make the decision to allow these iconic structures to be utilized as tactile exhibits the recommendation would be to provide at the base of each of these some type of very stable stepping stool or platform, similar to a library step stool. It would also be a possibility to produce replicated smaller scale versions of the iconic structures that are intentionally tactile exhibits. This would enable some visitors, especially children to tactilely examine the icons, exclusive of individuals with some physical disabilities. This would seem to be important so that individuals who have visual impairments can make the further connection with the audio description and the other symbolic icons.The movies are on a constant loop with very little time in between each of the 5 movies. This is the only time when the lights in the auditorium come up. As a result, there is not enough time when room is lit to be able to get the interpretive information from the iconic exhibits and photo panels. There are two recommendations that will help visitors get a better experience in the auditorium from the exhibits. The first is to start the movie beginning on the hour so visitors can schedule their viewing, and then create a break with the lights up, between each of the 5 movies. The park has also discussed emphasizing each iconic structure with a spotlight when it directly relates to the movie being played. This would give visitors an additional opportunity to explore the tactile exhibits and would benefit those who do not want to stay in the Auditorium for the full cycle of the movie(s).
Education and Justice
Stop two on the self guided tour is the Education and Justice gallery. Upon entering theroom, to the right is a long, angles counter mounted to the wall, a feature common to all four exhibit galleries.Above the counter, mounted to the wall, there is a series of graphics and text panels with historical notes about significant events and biographical information of key players. Currently, these panels are not portraying the same information to someone with low vision as to other visitors. Please refer to the section above relating to exhibit text to address these deficiencies. The track lighting used to illuminate these panels cast a glare on the text and also depending on the position of the visitor, a shadow making it even more difficult to read what is on the panels. Lighting is a reoccurring problem throughout the galleries and is addressed in a separate area of this narrative report. Please refer to that section and apply the same guidelines for the lighting illuminating these panels. Each of these elements separately are deficiencies, but when all of these elements are combined, it makes the readability of these panels that much more difficult.Embedded in the counter are two computer touch screen monitors presenting a computer interactive entitled “The Road to Justice.” This first person game explores, via a series of multiple-choice screens, the strategies available to those who fought against school segregation. It is a touch screen with no audio. Interactive computer kiosks are used throughout the galleries and have the same reoccurring deficiencies. Please refer to the separate section of this narrative report about the requirements for interactive computer kiosks to gain insight on how to better address the deficiencies applied to this exhibit. The angle at which these computers are displayed in the counter does not allow for proper viewing of the screen as it cannot be fully seen from a seated position. This not only affects visitors using a wheelchair, but also visitors who choose to sit down at the seats provided for this exhibit. By increasing the angle of the counters, it will help to make this exhibit more accessible to all visitors. There are two speakers mounted into the counter on both sides of the exhibit which gives visitors the impression that there is an audio component of the exhibit; which there is not. The recommendation is to remove the speakers and provide a cap and/or matching piece of material over the existing holes. This way visitors will not mistake the exhibit for having a function that is not working properly and it will also ensure that visitors who have low or no vision or who are deaf or have hearing loss are not under the impression that they are being denied an additional means of getting information from the exhibit.Also on the counter we find two flipbooks containing period images and explanatory text to provide additional information on Brown v. Board. The text found within the flip books are both black and red in color against a light blue background. The text is also a serif font and is too small. The red text against the blue background does not provide for a proper color contrast and would be difficult for a person with low vision to read. There is also a glare cast on the books from the track lighting that makes reading the pages much more difficult. Please see the section in this narrative report that deals with exhibit text and lighting to address this deficiency properly. The pages in the flipbooks were very hard to turn as a result of a lack of separation between the pages and the fact that the pages did not flip smoothly on the rings. A person with limited dexterity would have a difficult time being able to flip the pages. The recommendation is to find another method of fitting the pages on the rings that will allow for easier turning and to add tabs
at each page so that someone can more easily separate the pages to access them. A possible easy solution would be to provide larger holes to ensure the pages flip easier on the rings.Within the counter are four Discover Drawers that contain photos of plaintiffs and expert witnesses in the Brown cases. The pictures are backlit and the text is very small.Currently, a visitor with low or no vision may not receive the same information as other visitors. The information provided in the discover drawers shall be made available through an alternative format such as being included in the audio described tour that is recommended for the park to develop.The last exhibit found on this counter is the Myths v. Facts mechanical interactive. This exhibit presents the visitor with a series of common misconceptions about Brown v.Board. Adjacent to each statement is a roll-over that can be spun to reveal the correct answer. For visitors who need to operate this exhibit with a closed fist, the fact that the roller does not stay in place makes it difficult to read the information. The park should consider adding an audio component that would allow for a visitor to use an attached headset to receive the same information provided. An additional alternative for this exhibit would be to make it into a push button format, so that a person operating it with a closed fist could easily participate in the exhibit. The fact and fiction information should also be included in the audio described tour so that a person with low or no vision has the same opportunity to gain the same information from the exhibit as other visitors.To the left is the central hub structure with the timeline printed on its surface. Towards the center of the room, opposite the end-wall counter, is the exhibit wall that presents the video installation “The Five Lawsuits”. Mounted adjacent to each other on this wall are a cutout map of the United States and a 40 inch video monitor with a six-button selection panel. Five of the six buttons will play the stories of the five lawsuits that went on to be grouped by the Supreme Court under Brown v. Board. When any of these is activated, an LED lights up on the map denoting the location of the case. Additionally, the map is color-coded by state to denote the status, both legal and de facto, of segregation in that state at the time of Brown v. Board of Education. The sixth button plays an overview of the NAACP strategy; no lights are associated with it. The map provides a rare opportunity to incorporate a tactile exhibit into this site which is highly recommended. To make the map a tactile exhibit, remove the plexi-glass covering, lower the map to within reach range (the recommended reach ranges for children are 18 inches minimum to 44 inches maximum) and provide texture to the map to help denote segregation in each of the states. Tactile textures can be applied to the map to provide information degrees of segration. A rougher texture might indicate the states with the most segreation and varying degrees of texture types can be used to designate varying degrees of segration. The roughest surface material could denote the states and areas with the most segregation, and as one progresses to states where slavery was prohibited the surface would be smooth. The state boundaries should be tactile by providing a raised line.The Five Lawsuits video is open-captioned; however there is very little contrast between some of the backgrounds and the caption text which makes it difficult for persons with low vision to read. The park shall consider alternatives for providing a higher contrastingopen caption source. One possibility would be to provide white caption text within a black text band.The video information currently is not accessible to visitors who are blind and is required to be audio described. There is also not an assistive listening device available for persons with hearing loss to use when listening to this video as it is not broadcast through headphones but through open speakers. As a result of these videos being played over a set of speakers, they contribute to the various problems that this room in particular has with sound bleed and competing sounds. Two recommendations for this video would be to provide a sound cone overhead which would help to contain the sound and direct it to one central location as opposed to broadcasting it throughout the room. The volume of the movie could then potentially be lowered, which would in turn affect the volume of the other movies as well because they will not be competing at such a high volume. A second recommendation is to add a feature that will allow the visitor to stop the movie when they are done viewing it. Once you press the button to begin the movie it plays all the way through and after discussing the length of time spent at various exhibits with park staff, we found that the majority of visitors do not stay at this exhibit to follow it through to its end. A manual stop feature would help to eliminate extra sound when it is not needed.In addition, the text on the panel which labels which case is assigned to which button is not in an accessible text format. Please see the section of the narrative report that discusses accessible exhibit text.The next exhibit in the gallery is the video exhibit labeled “Hall of Courage”. This is an immersive audio-visual experience consisting of a long corridor. On the walls are rear projection video screens that are 14 feet in length and an array of eight speakers. The subject matter is large-as-life archival footage of confrontational events in the history of the Civil Rights movement. The movies run at four separate sections on the four screens. The intention is to provide the visitor with an experience of haste, confusion, rage and violence to better depict what it would have been like during that time. One cannot help but feel overwhelmed for a variety of reasons when you come out of the “Hall of Courage” and that feeling is very intentional on the part of the park. There are select words and phrases that are captioned in red text splashed in random locations across the screen; however the movies in their entirety are not open-captioned. The park shall provide open captioning for each of the individual screens of the movie.We understand the primary purpose of the “Hall of Courage” may not be to convey to the visitor all of the auditory information but rather to convey visually the experience of the events being depicted. We discussed the installation of sound cones above each of the screens to help direct the audio because when standing in the corridor it is very hard to decipher which audio is coming from which movie screen. This makes it difficult to describe what is happening in an adequate manner to a person with a visual impairment and would also make it difficult for a visitor with hearing loss to gain an equal experience from the hall.The “Hall of Courage” video runs on a continuous loop and so the audio is being heard at all times throughout the exhibit gallery. It is the loudest exhibit within the Education
and Justice gallery and providing breaks in the video when visitors are not watching it would help to minimize the amount of audio being heard throughout the exhibit. One way of accomplishing this without putting the video on a timer would be to install pressure mats at the entrance of the “Hall of Courage” corridor.The “Hall of Courage” exhibit relies on the visual characteristics of the video to convey the information and does so on four different screens always playing four different versions of the movie. This means that there are many flickering images all of the time, which would be over stimulating for someone with a seizure disorder. The most common type of seizure caused by this type of environment is called a photoepileptic seizure because they are brought on by pulses of light. Please see the following reference for more information on this disorder and the ways in which the park can improve the environment (http://www.webaim.org/articles/seizure/).Finally the video is not currently audio described and there is not an assistive listening system for visitors with hearing loss. Equal importance must be given to the description of what is displayed visually and to what can be heard in the audio tracks overlaid on the visuals up on the screen in “captioned graphics”. Please refer to the section of the narrative report on audio description and assistive listening systems for more information.The next exhibit is located in a small sit-down theater showing, They Gave Us Good Dreams. This is an 8-minute video program that explores the importance of education to the African American community. The video is open captioned however it currently is not audio described and there is not an assistive listening system available to visitors with hearing loss. The audio description of this video should include important factors such as speaker identification and descriptions of the photographs and important figures in them. Generally the audio described script does not identify the race of individuals, however, in the case of the videos in Brown v. Board and given the subject matter, it would be important to do so in the videos shown. Sound is again an issue in this theatre and several recommendations for the park are offered. The first is to replace the two speakers that are placed on the front wall on both sides of the screen with 2 smaller speakers. Then add two or more additional speakers along the back wall of the theatre so that the sound is dispersed and so the volume wouldn’t have to be played as loud to reach the visitors sitting in the theatre. An additional separate option would be to install sound cones over the seating area in the theatre, which would direct the sound instead of spreading it out. Please refer to the section of the narrative report that addresses sound.Along the end wall are hanging text and graphic panels and a long counter identical to the one on the opposite end of the gallery. Mounted within the counter is a mechanical interactive called Segregated Activities in which the player attempts to select from a list of activities which were segregated. There are a series of light boxes with buttons, each corresponding to an activity. When any button is pressed, the corresponding light box stays lit. There is a countdown at the end of the game which reveals that all of the activities were segregated. At the current angle of the counter, the answers in each of the boxes cannot be fully viewed by a person in a seated position. To address thisdeficiency the park shall adjust the angle of the counter so that it is at a greater viewing angle. Before adjusting the angle for both counters in the gallery, the park shall ensure that there is proper knee and toe clearance provided measured from the floor to the lowest point on the counter (ABAAS 306) (there is a lip under the counter that would be considered the lowest point).In addition to the interactive, there is another flipbook with information about slavery, the Civil War, reconstruction and Jim Crow. This flipbook should be altered to address the barrier issues identified about the first set of flipbooks in this same gallery. There are also four discover drawers. Within the drawers are photos and objects illustrating the culture and conditions of slavery. In one of the drawers is a manacle, which is what was used to chain the slaves. The Brown v. Board Park has very few tactile exhibits and providing a replica of the manacle would be a good tactile exhibit to provide to visitors with low or no vision. The material in the discover drawers and in the flipbook all need to be included in the audio described tour.
The Legacy of Brown v. Board of Education
Stop three on the self-guided tour is the Legacy of Brown v. Board of Education gallery. Upon entering the room, to the right is a similar long, angled counter mounted to the wall that is found in the four exhibit galleries. This gallery is dedicated to an exploration of the gains made by the modern Civil Rights movement that occurred subsequent to, and in large part because of, the Brown decision. The design and layout of the room mimics that of the other galleries.The Timeline continues on the central hub. The park shall ensure that the timeline found in each gallery is incorporated into the audio described tour. On the end-wall are the usual text-and-graphic panels. There is also a mechanical interactive that uses a revolving wheel to reveal facts about four historical figures from the modern Civil Rights Movement (displayed in small windows on the counter). The exhibit wheel cannot currently be operated with a closed fist. The park can easily remedy this by adding a perpendicular object to the wheel that would act as a lever so that visitors with low dexterity can operate the exhibit with a closed fist. The text on this exhibit is too small and has poor contrast, which makes it inaccessible for visitors with low vision.In the counter are two additional sets of Discovery Drawers containing more information from the Civil Rights Movement. There is also a pair of flipbooks with additional details on the modern Civil Rights Movement. Both of these exhibits should utilize to the same guidelines set forth in the other exhibit galleries and in the sections specifically related to exhibit text and hardware.Next is an area that addresses the topic of how the Brown decision and subsequent civil rights gains have provided models for progress by other groups, such as Native Americans and persons with disabilities, as well as for movements in other nations.However this information is portrayed on large floor to ceiling placards that do not provide a contrast between text and background, have text written in non-accessible serif font and have a tremendous amount of glare from the track lighting above. All of these factors combined make it very difficult if not impossible for a person with low
vision to get the same information that other visitors are receiving.The next exhibit is a video shown in a sit-down theater titled, Pass It On. This short film explores the current state of civil rights. The video alternates between the metaphorical dream-vision of a young man who sees figures from the past running through a desert landscape to reach one another and to keep a metaphorical “civil rights” baton moving forward. In addition the video presents day man-in-the-street interviews with youth revealing their impressions of the state of civil rights in the psyche of America’s youth. This video lacks an assistive listening system and audio description. Please refer to the section of the narrative report that addresses assistive listening and audio description.On the outside wall of the theatre is the video exhibit entitled What Do You Think. This exhibit is a simple PowerPoint presentation style with no audio and all text. The park shall ensure that the information provided at this exhibit is made available via the audio described tour.As found in the other galleries the end-wall has text and graphic panels, and there are also the flipbooks that are on the topics of the growth of African American scholarship and the impact of the US Civil Rights movement in South Africa. There is also a set of Discovery Drawers containing books and CDs by African American writers and musicians. Lastly, there is a pair of listening stations called “Music of Protest”. Visitors may don headphones and choose via a pushbutton panel from a selection of ten different songs. The park shall make available song lyrics scripts for visitors with hearing loss. These scripts will include the lyrics of each of the songs. In addition the park shall provide an assistive listening system at these stations.
Expression and Reflections
Stop four on the self-guided tour is the gallery Expression and Reflections. This gallery space provides a variety of activities to the visitor as well as is a place to simply sit and reflect. This space is also where the park houses its temporary exhibits.Along the edges of this gallery there are two flipbooks on podia. These contain highlights of artwork by Herb Taus depicting moments of conflict and social tolerance.Immediately to the right is a magnetic wallboard with a collection of words that can be used to create phrases, hopefully reflective of our thoughts on civil rights or race relations matters. We recommend the park provide word magnets with both Braille and print to allow users with visual impairments to fully participate in the activity provided.To the left, along the east wall, are four computer interactive kiosks. These are the “Expression Stations”, a computer interactive consisting of three primary activities designed to encourage expression on the part of the visitor. They are a drawing program, a message-writing program, and an audio recording program. In addition, there is an option to access a glossary of terms, a chronicle of relevant legal cases, a digital version of the timeline, and a compendium of messages and artistic creations from former visitors. These interactive computer kiosks have a knee clearance of just 24½ inches in height and a clear width of only 21 ½ inches. To properly use these exhibits,a parallel approach would not be appropriate which means that a forward approach would be needed. The park shall provide kiosks that meet the requirements for knee clearance and clear width for a wheelchair to pull underneath the kiosk (ABAAS 306). The angle at which these computers are displayed in the counter does not allow for proper viewing of the screen, as it cannot be fully seen from a seated position. This not only affects visitors using a wheelchair, but also visitors who choose to sit down at the seats provided for this exhibit. By increasing the angle of the counters, it will help to make this exhibit more accessible to all visitors.These interactive computer kiosks are touch screen and contain audio portions. These are the same interactive computer kiosks in terms of physical makeup used throughout the galleries and have the same physical reoccurring deficiencies. Please refer to the separate section of this narrative report about the requirements for interactive computer kiosks.These interactive computer kiosks are different from the others in that they do have an audio component. The park shall ensure that there is an assistive listening system provided for visitors with hearing loss.In the middle of the exhibit gallery panels are displayed that discuss the Chinese Exclusion Act. These panel exhibits are part of the park’s temporary exhibitions. The park has a responsibility to ensure that all programs provided by their park are accessible, and this is to include items such as temporary exhibits. The floor panels that are in the gallery are not accessible due to the text type, size and contrast. The information provided on the panels is also not being provided through an audio described tour. The park shall establish a set of criteria for all future temporary exhibits to ensure that they are hosting only accessible exhibits.
Bookstore
The bookstore is open during normal operating hours at Brown v. Board and offers the visitors the opportunity to purchase videos, music, books, patches, etc to remember their visit. Within the bookstore the carpet pad that was put down to protect the flooring is not firm enough. This significantly increases the amount of force (roll resistance) needed to propel a wheelchair over a surface. The firmer the carpeting and backing, the lower the roll resistance the surface will have. A pile thickness up to ½ inch is allowed, although a lower pile provides easier wheelchair maneuvering. If a backing, cushion or pad is used, it must be firm. The park must explore options for either removing the pad or providing a more accessible surface.There are approximately 20 – 25 movie titles available to purchase through the bookstore and it could not be verified that all titles were made available in a captioned version. The park shall decipher which videos they are currently selling that are not captioned and seek out a version that is. The bookstore also plays one of the videos that they sell during the day, and should ensure that it is played with captions displayed at all times.
Men’s Restroom
The exterior door is one in which you have to pull it towards you to open and the handle is currently just a loop. The existing loop handle does not provide enough of a gap between the handle and door to operate it with a closed fist.The mirror in the restroom is mounted so that the bottom edge of the reflective surface is 41 inches above the floor surface. Lower the mirror so that the bottom edge of the reflective surface is a maximum of 40 inches above the floor surface (ABAAS 603.3).The grab bars in the accessible stall are both (rear and side) too small by half an inch and are mounted at the incorrect location. Ensure that the rear grab bar is a minimum length of 36 inches and that the side grab bar is a minimum length of 42 inches.Remount according to the requirements in ABAAS 604.5.1 and 604.5.2.The changing station is out of reach range and needs to be lowered to ensure that the handle when folded upright (closed) is at a maximum height of 48 inches above the floor surface (ABAAS 308.2).Women’s Restroom
The grab bars in the accessible stall are both (rear and side) too small by half an inch and are mounted at the incorrect location. Ensure that the rear grab bar is a minimum length of 36 inches and that the side grab bar is a minimum length of 42 inches.Remount according to the requirements in ABAAS 604.5.1 and 604.5.2.Historic Structures Clause
The National Center on Accessibility recognizes that the Brown v. Board of Education structure qualifies as a Historic Structure. The fact that it is a historic structure does not exclude the park from complying with accessibility standards. Many parks around the country have been able to make changes to historic structures to bring them into compliance. Through NCA’s assessment of Brown v. Board of Education NHS, deficiencies were noted regardless of the classification of this structure. It is the park’s responsibility to decipher which, if any, of the deficiencies can be remedied. According to the new ABA standards, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation has established procedures for Federal agencies to meet this responsibility. Exceptions apply only when the State Historic Preservation Officer or the Advisory Council of Historic Preservation agrees that compliance would threaten or destroy the historic significance of the building or facility. The park should work with their Historic Preservation Specialists to determine what possible changes can be made.CORE PLANNING TEAM
Paul Adams, Topeka High School
Angela Estep, NPS-BRVB
Arlene Jackson, NPS-Ulysses S. Grant National Historic Site
Nathan McAlister, Royal Valley Middle School, Topeka
Beryl New, Highland Park High SchoolT
hom Rosenblum, NPS-BRVB
Dave Schafer, NPS-BRVB
Peggy Scherbaum, NPS-Harpers Ferry Center
Justin Sochacki, NPS-BRVB
Charles Scott, Jr., Attorney
Olivia Simmons, Visit Topeka, Inc. (CVB)
David Smith, NPS-BRVB
Joan Wilson, NPS-BRVB
Clara Wooden, NPS-Midwest Region Office
PLANNING CONSULTANTS
Ann Clausen, Vid Mednis, Interpretive Solutions, Inc.
IN APPRECIATION
The park administration would like to extend thanks to all of the community members and other interested parties who offered their advice and shared their concerns on how best to interpret the Brown v. Board of Education story. Special thanks go out to:
Jack Alexander, Community representative
Kerry Altenbernd, Black Jack Battlefield Trust
Cindy Barry, Washburn University Foundation
Sarah Bremer Parks, Community representative
David W. Carter, Bryan College
Marcia Cebulska, Playwright
Kelley Collins, NPS-Fort Scott National Historic Site
Katherine Cushinberry, NPS-BRVB Administrative Officer
Will Dale, Community representative
Anthony Fadale, State Accessibility coordinator
Aaron Firth, NPS-BRVB
Rev. Carl Frazier, Community representative
Joyce Grigsby, City of Topeka Human Relations Commission/ Community representative
Lisa Hammer, Community representative
Karen Hiller, Topeka City Council
June Jones, Community representative
Wendy Lauritzen, NPS-Tallgrass Prairie National Preserve
Mary Madden, Kansas State Historical Society
Julie McPike, Freedom’s Frontier National Heritage Area
Chris Meinhardt, Community representative
Nancy Overmeyer, Topeka and Shawnee County Public Library
Marie Pyko, Topeka and Shawnee County Public Library
Tom Richter, NPS-Chief of Interpretation and Education, Midwest Regional Office
Valerie Schafer, Western National Parks Association
Randal Standingwater, NPS-BRVB
Keith Tatum, Case, Inc.
Bill Wagnon, Shawnee County Historical Society
Eugene Williams, KTWU (Topeka’s public television station)
Mark Weaver, NPS-Nicodemus National Historic Site
Martin Wisneski, Washburn Law School
Last updated: August 24, 2023