H. Summary of Survey and Identification Methods Underground Railroad Travel Itinerary Header 

E. Statement of Historic Contexts
F. Associated Property Types
G. Geographical Data
I. Major Bibliographical References
Endnotes
Theme Study Home

H. SUMMARY OF SURVEY AND IDENTIFICATION METHODS



METHODOLOGY FOR NATIONAL HISTORIC LANDMARK EVALUATION

Twelve National Historic Landmarks have been designated under the Underground Railroad theme study as of August 6, 1998. The following section lists these properties and explains how they were selected.

The properties chosen for study as potential National Historic Landmarks began with the identification at the state level of all known properties relating to the Underground Railroad.  A list of properties was compiled, starting with those that were already listed in the National Register of Historic Places.  This list was augmented by information provided by State Historic Preservation Offices and other interested parties in response to a letter from National Park Service staff asking them to identify Underground Railroad related properties in thirty four states where Underground Railroad activity was conducted.

Information documenting the property's role in the Underground Railroad was collected. More than 100 site visits were made to properties that had a minimum level of documentation.  Properties that were determined to have sufficient supporting documentation were considered further.  Properties chosen for consideration for National Historic Landmark study were ones that had both high integrity and that were either associated with nationally significant figures connected with the Underground Railroad or that were importantly representative in some national context.  The properties thus far designated under this theme study are:

Fort Mose Site, St. Johns County, Florida
Fort Mose is a precursor site of the Underground Railroad, demonstrating that resistance to slavery was both early and fierce, and that it arose decades before abolitionism became organized and influential. Established during the mid-eighteenth century as a Spanish military post, it was the earliest known legally sanctioned free black community in the present United States.

Owen Lovejoy House, Princeton, Illinois
Owen Lovejoy, an influential abolitionist politician, lived here from 1838 until his death in 1864.  He used this home to harbor fugitive slaves on their way north and several times he faced prosecution in the courts for his role in the Underground Railroad.  Elected to Congress in 1856, he gained a national reputation through his congressional and party leadership and fiery anti-slavery speeches on the floor of the House.

Eleutherian College Classroom and Chapel Building, Lancaster, Indiana
Constructed between 1854 and 1856, this building is the only surviving building with integrity associated with one of the first colleges west of the Allegheny Mountains to promote college-level equal educational experiences prior to the Civil War.  Families affiliated with the Neil's Creek Abolitionist Baptist Church were responsible for the founding and administration of Eleutherian College and were involved in the clandestine activities of the Underground Railroad.  As a hotbed of abolitionism, Lancaster was well-known as a stopping point for slaves seeking refuge on their way to freedom.

John Rankin House, Ripley, Ohio
This was the home of Presbyterian minister John Rankin, who is reputed to have been one of Ohio's first and most active "conductors" on the Underground Railroad.  In addition, he wrote Letters on American Slavery, first published in book form in 1826, and among the first clearly articulated antislavery views printed west of the Appalachians, which became standard reading for abolitionists all over the United States.  From 1822 to 1865, Rankin, along with his wife and children, assisted hundreds of escaped slaves in their trek to freedom.

John P. Parker House, Ripley, Ohio
A former slave, John Parker's unflagging and oftentimes heroic efforts to rescue escaped slaves from the "borderlands" along the Ohio River underscores the major role played by African-Americans not only as slaves and fugitives, but as rescuers on the Underground Railroad as well.  Parker was not an outspoken abolitionist and appears never to have joined or participated in the antislavery societies.  However, he repeatedly secreted himself back into slave territory to assist escaped slaves and to lead them to safety across the Ohio River.

F. Julius Le Moyne House, Washington, Pennsylvania
This house was the residence of Dr. F. Julius LeMoyne from 1827 until his death in 1879.  LeMoyne joined the anti-slavery movement in 1834 at the point when it was becoming popularized and politicized among the white middle class across the country.  In his activism and philosophy LeMoyne represents the mainstream of anti-slavery activity in the United States before 1850.  His philosophy of legitimate activism distinct from his willingness to abet fugitive slaves illuminates the variation of personal conscience at work on all Americans as they struggled with the issues of political authority, human rights, and personal property in the debate over slavery.

Rokeby, Ferrisburgh, Vermont
Key to Rokeby's historic significance is its extensive and rare contemporary documentation.  Family letters not only validate Rokeby as a stop, they add to our knowledge, correcting and sharpening our understanding of the Underground Railroad and providing insight into how "the legend outgrew the reality."  No other known Underground Railroad site matches Rokeby for this combination of documentation and completeness and historical integrity of site and collections.

Johnson House, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
 Philadelphia was a center of the nineteenth century American movement to abolish slavery, and the Johnson House is one of the key sites of that movement.  The Johnson House is a representative station on the Underground Railroad and the Johnsons among the leading abolitionist families of their generation.  Working closely with black and white abolitionists and assisting fugitive slaves and freedmen on their journeys to freedom, the Johnson family were typical of the conscience reformers who participated in the Underground Railroad.

Wilson Bruce Evans House, Oberlin, Ohio
Constructed in 1854-56, this house was the home of Wilson Bruce Evans, a leading African-American abolitionist and successful member of Oberlin's commercial and educational communities.  Wilson Bruce Evans and his brother Henry Evans were participants in the well-known  1858 Oberlin-Wellington Rescue.  This rescue of an escaped slave, who had been captured and was to be taken back to his master in Kentucky, was one of several open and well-publicized confrontations over the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 and was significant in fueling the sectional differences in the United States prior to the Civil War.

Austin F. Williams Carriagehouse and House, Farmington, Connecticut
This property achieves its greatest national significance for its direct connection with the celebrated Amistad affair of 1839-1841.  In this complex legal case that ensued from a slave revolt on the high seas in 1839, the institution of slavery was challenged for the first time in the United States Supreme Court.  In March 1841, those who had participated in the revolt, were released from prison and were housed in quarters provided by Austin F. Williams, a known abolitionist, on this site, now part of the extant carriagehouse.

John Brown Farm and Gravesite, Lake Placid, New York
The John Brown Farm is significant for its association with and as a commemorative memorial to the famous and controversial abolitionist John Brown.  It was from this farm that Brown set forth to Harpers Ferry with his plan to end slavery through armed confrontation, and here where his body was returned for burial following his execution for treason and murder in 1859.  The very early efforts to preserve the site as a memorial to Brown and his fallen followers speak to the intensity with which Brown's crusade gripped the American consciousness in the years before the Civil War.  The continued memorial efforts at the site for more than a century after his death illustrate the heroic status he came to acquire.

Milton House, Milton, Wisconsin
The Milton House illustrates the westward spread of abolition and its transformation from a moral to a political issue. The founder of the town of Milton and proprietor of the Milton House, Joseph Goodrich, was one of many to leave the "Burned-over District" in western New York to settle in Wisconsin, taking the reform movement and its ideals westward.  In Wisconsin the issue of abolitionism became strongly politicized, the "free soil" doctrine becoming a key tenet of the Republican party when it was founded in the state in 1854.  Joseph Goodrich and his activities at the Milton House illustrate this particular brand of abolitionism that developed in the Middle West in the 1840s.  
 
National Register Home | NHL Home | History Home | Aboard the Underground Railroad  

Comments or Questions