The success of this project was almost guaranteed from the outset
by the willingness of Wake Forest University (WFU) to follow the
recommendations of the historical landscape architects. WFU recognized
the uniqueness of this undertaking and retained a team of design
professions skilled in addressing historic landscape issues. As
difficult issues arose, WFU was receptive to doing what was deemed
'best' for the historic character of the garden. Budget was always
important, but was not the only consideration in decision-making.
During the development of the cultural landscape report, the project
landscape architects benefited from a National Park Service educational
offering, "A Forum on Vegetative Management for Historic Sites,"
offered at Arnold Arboretum in Boston in August 1995. The day-long
series of speakers provided helpful insight used in guiding this
project. From this workshop, the following summary points were incorporated
in the Reynolda Gardens rehabilitation project:
Evaluate the original design intent within the context of today's
landscape;
- All vegetation has a life span,
decline and replacement is inevitable; the replacement plant material
determines the level of authenticity;
- Historic vegetation is fragile
and vulnerable;
- Utilize the knowledge of the garden
staff; collaboration results in support for the project; and
- Recognize the realities of maintenance.
The original intent by designers Miller, Buckenham, and Sears,
and designer/owner, Katharine Smith Reynolds was immediately recognized
in the project. The desire of Sears and KSR was for an open spacious
landscape with views framed by strategically placed vegetation and
axial pathways was lost in the overgrown vegetation and the deteriorated
condition of many of the original plantings. Vegetation management
was a top priority.
Replacement of historic vegetation was the most difficult decision
to make. Removal of the Japanese cedar allée was a controversial
action, but was somewhat tempered by the successful propagation
of the original plants. The propagated plants have performed exceptionally
well and were returned to the garden in early 2000, several years
ahead of schedule.
The application of new technologies has been successful. The polypropylene
mesh subsurface treatment worked. The grassed pathways, except in
a few shady spots, show little signs of wear from the heavy pedestrian
traffic. The roots of the Bermuda grass extend over a foot below
surface, illustrating the healthy condition of the turf. The moisture
problems associated with the retaining walls have disappeared. The
outer surface shows no signs of scaling or peeling. The barrier
free ramp has been deemed almost too successful. It is so unobtrusive
that visitors can't find it and when they do, they are sometimes
reluctant to walk on the grass. Strategic signage is now being used
to direct people to the ramp.
The gardens' staff was a major partner to the designers in all
phases of the project. They assisted in the development of the plan's
recommendations, particularly in identifying maintenance implications
in various design options, and implementing many of the plan's recommendations.
The completed plan has been well received by the garden staff, university,
and local community as well as numerous out-of-state and out-of-country
visitors. The gardens, which provide for both passive use and organized
programs, welcome over 100,000 visitors yearly twenty-four hours
a day free of charge.
Reynolda House and the gardens were featured on television in the
American Castles series titled, "Gardens and Galleries." This exposure
continues to attract visitors with an increase in visitation, observed
by staff, each time the show is aired. Reynolda Gardens has apparently
'recovered' from the 'stress' of project implementation. Garden
staff found it humorous that current visitors, particularly garden-focused
groups, don't believe the garden has been recently rehabilitated.
The garden's curator of education says she frequently has to provide
photographs of the construction work to prove the point.