Beginning with the garden's plant materials, crabapples (Malus
sp.) had been planted in the interior of each of the four quadrants
(four in each) in the early 1970s - even though the original saucer
magnolias (Magnolia soulangeana) remained, though in varying conditions.
The garden's circulation features, namely the pathways in each of
the quadrants, originally grass, were paved with slate to address
intense pedestrian traffic. The original layout of the pathways
was also changed at that time. Neither the color nor pattern of
slate matched the original slate border.
Repairs were also made to the surface of many of the retaining
walls during the 1970s and again in the 1980s. None of these repairs
had corrected apparent moisture problems, as evidenced by the deteriorated
condition of the walls' stucco-type surfacing. Exploratory demolition
was carried out on a section of the walls to determine the extent
of damage and the construction techniques. The initial demolition
revealed that the foundation was three feet deep with later investigations
showing that the foundation ranged from two to five feet below grade.
Apparently Sears had used a design more suitable for his home in
Philadelphia, where the frost line is greater that the one to one-half
feet specified as the appropriate foundation depth for the Winston-Salem
area. Core samples were also taken and evaluated by a geologist/petrographer,
who determined that the walls exhibited "the beginning stages of
sulfate attack" and lacked "air-entrainment." Air-entrainment concrete
was not introduced until the 1930s, many years after the construction
of the walls. It is able to produce microscopic air bubbles within
the hardened concrete that serve as pressure release chambers for
expansion. The sulfate problem is a complex chemical process, but
begins with water mixing with the original concrete or organism
growth on the concrete. Together these conditions had caused the
cracking and scaling on the wall surfaces. Nevertheless, the eighty-year
old walls were deemed repairable. Severely deteriorated sections
were to be removed while minor repairs were recommended for less
damaged sections.
In the 1970s, the wood portions of the teahouses and east and
west garden features were rebuilt. The original Lion's Head Fountain
was altered with the replacement of the rear wall and re-tiling
of the pool's interior. The replacement wall differed from the arched
form of the original, and the color and texture of the new tile
did not match the original.
During this period, the garden was not universally accessible.
Visitors in wheelchairs were unable to enter the sunken garden.
The garden staff found it difficult to move equipment into the lower
garden using the existing steps.
The vegetation in the garden had become overgrown, and no longer
satisfying the spatial intent of the original design. Boxwood hedges
containing historic, as well as nonhistoric, plants were several
times their original size, and, together with English ivy, had overtaken
most of the perennial beds. Much of the extant historic vegetation
was in a deteriorated state, particularly the Japanese cedar and
Japanese weeping cherries (Prunus subhirtella pendula).
The original rose quadrants had been removed and, in 1972, the
southernmost third of the vegetable garden was replanted as a rose
garden by the Winston-Salem Rose Society. Both the vegetable and
rose gardens required a high amount of maintenance, which consumed
much of the garden staff's time.