National Park Service National Park Service

Whitman Mission NHS - History & Culture
 
 

The Sun Never Set:
The American Board's World Wide Missionary Effort

By Rick Laughlin


1810 -- a year best remembered as the height of Napoleon Bonaparte's career. He had conquered much of Europe and was locked in a fierce struggle with Britain. In the Western hemisphere, the vast Spanish empire began to collapse as a revolt against imperial rule broke out in Venezuela. Here in the United States, public anger continued to rise over the British practice of forcing American sailors into the Royal Navy. Other significant events also happened in the same year. The most relevant event for the history of Waiilatpu was that the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions was established in Massachusetts. This was the same organization that sent Marcus and Narcissa Whitman into the Pacific Northwest twenty six years later to a mission station considered more remote than Africa.

The American Board therefore played a crucial role in the history of Waiilatpu and the Pacific Northwest. As a result, many interesting questions arise about this organization such as who established the American Board and what was its objective? How was the organization affected by some of the important historical events of the nineteenth century? How did the technology of that same century affect the American Board's operations in the Pacific Northwest? Finally, what was the eventual fate of this organization and what was their legacy?

The effort to found the American Board was led by a man named Samuel Mills. He wanted to establish an organization which would fulfill Jesus Christ's command for his disciples to "Go ye therefore, and teach all nations…" Mr. Mills thought of this idea in 1806 when he was a student at Williams College in Massachusetts. He found several other students who supported this concept and the group established the "Society of Brethren" in 1808. This society's objective was to promote the idea of establishing missions outside the United States. Mr. Mills and one of his friends from the society continued to recruit supporters when they became students at the Andover Theology Seminary in 1810. Mr. Mills' dream became a reality during that same year when the Society of Brethren persuaded the General Association of Congregational Ministers of Massachusetts to establish the American Board. Many other Congregational and Presbyterian groups also began supporting the American Board.

The first American Board mission was established two years later in India. Several members of this mission were Andover alumni who had worked with Mr. Mills to establish a foreign missionary organization. Since Mr. Mills had worked so long to establish missions in other countries, it is interesting to see that he also wanted to establish missions for the Native Americans. These tribes did not speak English as a native language and the American Board therefore viewed them as being within the realm of their conversion efforts. In 1816, the American Board established their first Native American mission amongst the Cherokee people of the southeastern United States. The American Board also continued to set up missions throughout the world in locations such as Turkey, South Africa, Burma, China, Singapore and Hawaii.

These missions all reported to a "Prudential Committee" that was located in Boston. The Committee handled the organization's fundraising and administrative tasks. The Whitmans' main contact with the Committee was through Reverend David Greene. His letters to Dr. Whitman and the Whitmans' responses are among the most important primary sources from Waiilatpu's history.

The operations at Waiilatpu and the other American Board stations were part of the "Second Great Awakening," a series of religious revival movements that swept through the United States during the first half of the nineteenth century. Mr. Mills and his fellow students at Williams College were amongst the many Americans who were affected by this movement. The Second Great Awakening also strengthened the ties between the Presbyterian and Congregational Churches in the U.S. This made it easier for these groups to work together in organizations such as the American Board. Yet another byproduct of the Second Great Awakening was that it encouraged the founding of seminaries such as Andover. Similar seminaries were established in Bangor, Maine and Hartford, Connecticut.

The American Board was also affected by other events that took place in the United States during the nineteenth century, including the Panic of 1837. This recession produced a steep drop in the amount of donations made to the American Board. Indeed, Reverend Greene sent out a letter in 1837 which warned the Whitmans and the Spaldings of the dire financial situation. The letter said that the Pacific Northwest missions would be limited to a budget of one thousand dollars each year. The letter also stated that there was a high probability that the budget would be reduced even further. This allocation had to cover the operations of both Waiilatpu and Reverend Henry Spalding's Lapwai mission near present-day Lewiston, Idaho.

As it turned out, the limitation of one thousand dollars per year was never actually enforced. In fact, 1842 and 1847 were the only two years during Waiilatpu's eleven year history where the annual expenses were less than one thousand dollars. These expenses were for items such as furniture, tools and other items that were sold by the Hudson's Bay Company. Dr. Whitman and the other missionaries tried to reduce these bills by becoming as self-sufficient as possible.

However, the effort to obtain self-sufficiency reduced the amount of time that the missionaries had available to teach the natives about Christianity. This problem became even more severe for the Whitmans once Waiilatpu became a way station on the Oregon Trail. Reverend Greene expressed his concern in a letter that he wrote on April 6, 1846. He was worried that the Whitman Mission was rapidly turning into "a great restaurant for the weary pilgrims on their way to the promised land." Reverend Greene also feared that the Cayuse would view Dr. Whitman as a businessman as opposed to a missionary. He felt that the Cayuse would then become less interested in learning about Christianity and more interested in making money.

The typical nineteenth century American Board missionary definitely did not have much interest in becoming wealthy. Indeed, the organization's missionaries did not even receive salaries! This factor helped the American Board survive the financial crisis of 1837 and the organization even expanded its Pacific Northwest operations in 1839 when two new missions were established. These missions were the Tshimakain Mission near present-day Spokane, Washington and the Kamiah Mission near present-day Kamiah, Idaho. The Tshimakain Mission was operated by Reverend Elkanah Walker, Reverend Cushing Eells and their wives. The Kamiah Mission was run by Reverend Asa Smith and his wife.

Reverend Smith did not get along with his fellow missionaries and he also became very unhappy about living in the Idaho wilderness. He expressed his frustration by writing many letters to the American Board headquarters. These letters featured a wide variety of bitter complaints about Reverend Henry Spalding. Mr. William Gray, a handyman and carpenter who worked with both Dr. Whitman and Reverend Spalding, also sent several similar letters back to Boston.

These hand-written letters traveled at a speed that was painfully slow by modern standards. Documents had to be sent either on a ship or by overland travelers such as Hudson's Bay Company employees. It took about seven months for a letter to travel across the overland continental route and fourteen months by ship around Cape Horn, South America.

Since the communication methods were so slow, it was difficult for the Prudential Committee to obtain Reverend Spalding's views. The Committee therefore decided to take the drastic measure of dismissing Reverend Spalding, Reverend Smith and Mr. Gray. These individuals were ordered to leave the Pacific Northwest. Dr. Whitman was to be reassigned to work with Reverend Walker and Reverend Eells at the Tshimakain Mission.

Dr. Whitman decided to challenge this order, making his famous journey east in the winter of 1842 to plead his case before the American Board in Boston. His travelling methods show another way in which the technology of the period affected the American Board's operations. Since automobiles and planes had not been invented yet, Dr. Whitman had to travel most of the way on horseback. He was then able to travel on steamboats once he reached the Midwest. Dr. Whitman was able to persuade the Prudential Committee to cancel its order and he returned to his mission in 1843. The American Board's operations at Waiilatpu continued another four years. These activities abruptly ended when the Whitmans were killed on November 29, 1847.

The American Board, however, continued to run its missions in other parts of the world well into the twentieth century. Indeed, Reverend Walker and Mrs. Walker's grandchildren became American Board missionaries in China and South Africa during the 1920's and 1930's. The twentieth century also witnessed the absorption of the American Board into the United Board for World Ministries in 1961. This group is a part of the United Church of Christ and they still have active missions all over the world. So, part of the American Board's legacy is an ongoing attempt to fulfill Christ's command to his disciples.

In order to achieve their objective, the United Church missionaries still perform tasks similar to those mentioned in Mrs. Narcissa Whitman's letters. For example, a group of United Church missionaries in Haiti regularly hold prayer meetings and build churches. In addition to conversion efforts, the United Church missionaries also perform social work. The organization runs a school for African children in Botswana and helps to fund hospitals in the African country of Lesotho.

The American Board also has a legacy here in the Pacific Northwest because some of the modern descendants of the Cayuse and Nez Perce tribes are Presbyterians. There is currently a Presbyterian church on the Umatilla Reservation in Oregon and there are six Presbyterian churches on the Nez Perce Reservation in Idaho.

The Whitmans and the other American Board missionaries who worked with these tribes were well aware that they were part of a larger effort. Perhaps this feeling was best expressed in a letter that Reverend Greene wrote to the Pacific Northwest missions on March 13, 1845. In this letter, he informed the missionaries that the American Board wanted its missionaries to say a "special prayer" at the same time as the Prudential Committee's annual meeting. The prayer was aimed at:

"…securing the blessing of God upon the deliberations & proceedings of the Board during its session; upon the Prudential Committee during the ensuing year, & the missionaries & agents laboring under its direction; & upon the several missions, & the churches which contribute for their support."

The Whitmans' labors for the American Board ended only a few years after Reverend Greene's request. Their lives had been dedicated towards what Reverend Greene described as "the general work of planting and sustaining the standard of Christ in Oregon." If it had not been for the American Board, then the Whitmans might have spent their lives elsewhere. Perhaps the Methodists or the Roman Catholics would have established a mission at Waiilatpu instead. But, the existence of the American Board allowed the Whitmans to be the ones who worked at Waiilatpu for what Mrs. Whitman felt was "the cause of Christ in this land."


Page Navigation

Top of page

History Menu Bar

Education Menu Bar

Main Menu Bar


Privacy & Disclaimer
Webmaster: Renee Rusler
Last modified on: March 29, 2004