CHAPTER 2
Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Lakes in the Glacially Influenced Landscape of the
North Cascades Mountain Range, Washington State, USA


RESULTS

Date of ice-out increased with increasing lake elevation on the east slope (r2 = 0.259, N = 16, P = 0.044) and on the west slope (r2 = 0.621, N = 39, P < 0.001) of the park. East-slope subalpine lakes iced-out earlier that did west-slope subalpine lakes (P = 0.01). This result occurred even though the average elevation of east-slope subalpine lakes was higher than the average elevation of west-slope subalpine lakes (Table 2.1).

On average, NOCA lakes were relatively cold, neutral in pH, and low in dissolved substances and concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus (Table 2.5). However, considerable variation was observed for most variables. Water temperature, pH, alkalinity, conductivity, total Kjeldahl-N, and ammonia-N of west-slope lakes decreased in concentration and nitrate-N increased in concentration with increased elevation (Table 2.6). Only total phosphorus and orthophosphate-P did not change in concentration relative to elevation (Table 2.6). However, when three lakes (two alpine and one subalpine) receiving turbid-glacial outwash were deleted from the data set, total phosphorus increased with decreasing elevation (Table 2.6). Changes in vegetation zone were related to elevation as well. East-slope subalpine lakes were significantly higher in pH, alkalinity, total phosphorus, and total Kjeldahl-N than were west-slope subalpine lakes (Table 2.7).

Table 2.5. Average water quality of west-slope and east-slope NOCA study lakes.

VariableUnitsnAverage RangeSD

Temperature°C5111.6 1.3-21.04.7
pHStandard587.03 5.9-8.7--
Alkalinitymg/l582.6 0.4-20.53.4
Conductivitymg/l5824.2 1.9-156.929.4
Total Kjeldahl-Nmg/l58 0.0490.01*-0.1940.045
Nitrate-Nmg/l580.007 0.001*-0.0350.008
Ammonia-Nmg/l580.005 0.005*-0.0200.004
Total phosphorusmg/l58 0.0070.001*-0.0300.006
Orthophosphate-Pmg/l580.001 0.001*-0.0060.001

*detection limits

Table 2.6. Regression analyses of water quality variables and begetation zone as independent variables and elevation as the dependent variable for west-slope NOCA lakes.

VariablenSign of the
Regression
Coefficient
r2P

Temperature37-0.475<0.001
pH40-0.363<0.001
Alkalinity40-0.400<0.001
Conductivity40-0.425<0.001
Total Kjeldahl-n40-0.477<0.001
Nitrate-N40+0.1110.036
Ammonia-N40-0.1480.014
Total Phosphorus40-0.0610.123
Orthophosphate-P40-0.0050.655
Total Phosphorus137-0.2320.003
Vegetation Zone40-0.661<0.001

1Two alpine lakes and 1 subalpine lake receiving turbid-glacial meltwater were deleted.

Table 2.7. Comparisons of water qualities of west-slope subalping lakes (n=16) and east-slope subaline (n=9) lakes, NOCA.

VariableAverage Values
P*
West slopeEast slope

Temperature (1989; °C)10.9 13.60.074
pH (Standard units)6.77.00.041
Alkalinity (mg/l)1.11.80.026
Conductivity (µS/cm)14.916.40.353
Total Kjeldahl-N (mg/l)0.0240.0550.016
Nitrate-N (mg/l)0.0080.0070.871
Ammonia-N (mg/l)0.0060.0050.780
Total Phosphorus (mg/l)0.0050.0090.002
Orthophosphate-P (mg/l)0.0010.0010.637

*Mann-Whitney U-test

Based on the second discriminant analysis, using six water quality variables and elevation as independent variables with vegetation zone as the dependent variable, 98.2% of the among-group variation was found to be associated with the first two canonical variates; 93.3% was associated with variate 1 and 4.9% with variate 2. Canonical variate 1 was positively correlated with elevation and negatively correlated with alkalinity, conductivity, total Kjeldahl- N, and pH (Table 2.8). Canonical variate 2 was most strongly and positively correlated with orthophosphate-P and nitrate-N (Table 2.8). The effectiveness of this model in placing lakes into the correct vegetation zone-based classification categories was somewhat problematic, however, since 13 of the 58 lakes (22.4%) were misclassified.

Table 2.8. Correlation of independent variables and canonical variates one and two determined during the second discriment analysis.

VariableCanonical
Variate 1
Canonical
Variate 2

Elevation0.623-0.066
pH-0.324-0.112
Alkalinity-0.5070.241
Conductivity-0.4650.151
Total Kjeldahl-N-0.387-0.114
Nitrate-N0.1860.505
Orthophosphate-P-0.0350.784

Collectively, shallow lakes (<10 m in maximum depth) exhibited a wide range of values for alkalinity and conductivity, and concentrations of total Kjeldahl-N and total phosphorus. A greater percentage of shallow lakes maintained high values of the variables than did deep lakes (Table 2.9).

Table 2.9. Number of shallow (<10 m) and deep (>10 m) lakes exhibiting elevated conductivity, alkalinity, and concentrations of total Kjeldahl-N and total phosphorus. Possible numbers of lakes: shallow (38), deep (19).

VariableConcentration
or Level
Number of Percentage
of Lakes
<10 m%10 m%

Conductivity25 µS/cm 1437316
Alkalinity3 mg/L 1232316
Total Kjeldahl-N0.08 mg/L 102615
Total Phosphorus0.008 mg/L 1437316

Geology did not play a major role in segregating most NOCA lakes based on water quality. For example, water quality of lakes in granitic or gneiss basins, the primary geologic substrates, did not differ (see Lomnicky 1996). The few low-forest lakes in watersheds with greenstone outcroppings were higher (P = 0.025) in alkalinity and conductivity than were low- forest lakes in either gneiss or granite bedrock watersheds (Table 2.10).

Table 2.10. Comparisons of conductivity and alkalinity of low-forest west-side lakes in basins with gneiss or granite and those in greenstone (n=3).

VariableAverage Value (Minimum - Maximum)P
Gneiss - GraniteGreenstone

Conductivity µS/cm48.2 (11.4-20.5) 119.9 (97.2-157.0)0.025
Alkalinity mg/L5.4 (2.6-7.5) 48.2 (21.0-65.7)0.025

Chapter 2


Abstract | Introduction | Study Area | Methods | Results | Discussion | Literature Cited


Chapter 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7


http://www.nps.gov/noca/trout2/trout2d.htm
Last Updated: 01-Feb-2000