National Park Service arrowhead logo National Park Service, US Department of Interior
Visit ParkWise!Home for ParkWiseTeacher Resources Student Resources

Introduction

Task

Process
Quick Look
Legal Experts
Scientific Consultants
Cultural Representatives
Policy Symposium

ParkWise > Teachers > Perspectives >Final Activity

Final Activity:
Introduction

Should National Park Managers accept the Plate Boundary Observatory proposal?

Welcome to the Policy Symposium on the Plate Boundary Observatory proposal put before the National Parks Service in Alaska by EarthScope.

EarthScope is an organization dedicated to providing a foundation for fundamental and applied research throughout the United States that will contribute to the mitigation of risks from geological hazards, the development of natural resources, and the public's understanding of the dynamic Earth. In this proposal, EarthScope scientists want to place the PBO installations or monuments in or near wilderness lands in Alaska. As experts in the science, legal and local communities, you have been called together to evaluate this proposal and make a recommendation to the parks service.

Some managers, seeing ever increasing threats to wilderness, may be relatively undecided about the need for or importance of many proposed scientific activities in designated or suitable for wilderness areas. Others may agree with Graber (1988), a research scientist with extensive experience working in national park wilderness, who suggests that:

"… the appropriate standard that managers must apply is whether the benefits that will accrue to wilderness conservation, society-in-general, or human knowledge…by scientific research outweigh the costs imposed on wilderness by those research activities."

Sources for the framework and handouts of this activity:

  1. A Framework for Evaluating Proposals for Scientific Activities in Wilderness by Peter Landres
  2. The Challenge of Doing Science in Wilderness: Historical, Legal and Policy Context by Peter Landres, Judy Alderson and David J. Parsons

> Task >